Horror logo

Scratch IV

Four walls

By K-jayPublished about 8 hours ago • Updated about 3 hours ago • 12 min read

The door closed behind her.

And the darkness swallowed the sound.

Melissa did not know how long she sat on the edge of the narrow bunk before she understood that no one was coming to get her. The cell was smaller than the interview room at the precinct, smaller than the conference room at the courthouse, smaller than any room she had ever slept in. Concrete walls. A steel toilet in the corner. A thin mattress that smelled of bleach and other people's sweat.

Somewhere down the corridor, a woman was crying. Somewhere else, a guard's keys rattled, slow and unhurried, as if time itself had been told to wait outside.

She kept her hands in her lap. She could still feel the handcuffs, even though they were gone. The small, delicate click of them closing in the courtroom kept playing back in her ears, over and over, the way a song gets stuck when you only know one line of it.

*Tell them about Rebecca.*

She had said that to Harrison as they took her away. *Tell them I saved her.*

She had believed, all the way into the precinct that first night, that saving Rebecca would be enough. That the truth would be obvious once it was laid out in front of people. The photographs. The hidden compartment. The medication records. Daniel, drugged in the trunk of her own SUV, beside the woman he had tried to kill.

But Daniel had given them another story, and his story was simpler. A sadistic wife. An exhausted husband. A woman who had planned it all.

Simpler stories win. That was the first thing she learned in custody.

The second thing she learned was that the silence here was different from the silence at home. At home, the silence had been heavy, suffocating, full of things she was afraid to hear. Here, the silence was thin. It let every small sound through. The buzz of the fluorescent light overhead. The drip of a faucet she could not see. The faint scratch of something, somewhere behind the wall.

She froze.

It was faint. Very faint. Not the scratching from the apartment, not yet — just a small sound, somewhere behind the wall. A nail, maybe. A pipe settling.

She told herself that. She said it out loud, very quietly, so the sound of her own voice would cover it.

"It's a pipe."

The scratching stopped.

She did not sleep that night. She lay on her back and watched the light buzz, and every time she closed her eyes she saw the television in the courthouse corridor, her name beneath the headline about the missing women, and Daniel, somewhere beyond those walls, still alive. Still breathing. Still waiting.

---

Harrison came the next morning.

He did not look like a man who had slept, either. His suit was the same one from yesterday, his tie loosened, his eyes red at the edges. He sat across from her in a room that smelled of disinfectant and old coffee, a folder on the table between them, and he did not waste time on comfort.

"You are charged as an accomplice," he said. "Not as the mastermind. Not yet. The district attorney chose the accomplice theory because it is the one they think they can prove."

"Prove what?" Melissa said. Her voice sounded strange to her, hoarse from a night of not speaking. "That I was there? I was there. I told them I was there."

"That you participated," Harrison said. "That you knew, and that you helped, and that you waited."

He opened the folder. Inside were copies of the things she had already seen in Miller's office, and copies of things she had not. Daniel's statement, typed and neat. The surveillance notes tracking Rebecca Lawson, in her handwriting. The medication log from the nursing home. A photograph of the hidden compartment, open, the boxes inside it lit up by a flash.

"They have Daniel saying you forced him to steal the vials," Harrison said. "They have your search history. They have the fact that you lived with him for fourteen days after you found that closet and you did not call the police. And they have the injection. You admit you gave it to him. The prosecution will say that is attempted murder, even if you say it was to save Rebecca."

"I did save her," Melissa said.

"I know," Harrison said. "And I will say that, in every room they let me say it in. But you need to understand what we are up against. A jury will hear that you made love to your husband the night you found out he was a killer. They will hear that you drove to a parking lot and watched a woman get taken. They will hear that the only person with a lethal dose of sedatives in his blood that night was Daniel. Those facts are true, Melissa. They just do not mean what Daniel says they mean."

She looked down at her hands. They were shaking again, the way they had shaken on the steering wheel.

"Can you get me out?" she asked. "Bond?"

Harrison hesitated, and in that hesitation she had her answer.

"We can appeal the bond decision," he said. "We will. But the judge has already heard the prosecution's argument, and he has already decided you are a risk. I do not want to lie to you about our chances."

"So I stay here."

"For now," Harrison said. "While we build the case."

"What case?" she said. "What case do we have?"

Harrison closed the folder, very slowly, as if he were trying not to frighten her.

"We have the truth," he said. "We just have to find a way to make it sound as simple as his lie."

---

Daniel was not in a cell like hers.

That was the first thing Miller told Harrison, and Harrison told Melissa, and Melissa tried not to think about what it meant. Daniel was in custody, yes, but he was in a medical holding unit, still weak from the overdose, still under observation, with a lawyer who visited twice a day and a nurse who checked his vitals every four hours.

He was calm. That was what unsettled everyone who spoke to him. He did not shout. He did not demand. He answered questions in a low, tired voice, and he cried at exactly the right moments, and he kept saying the same thing, in different words, every time.

He had been afraid of his wife. He had tried to stop. He had finally told her no, in that parking lot, and she had tried to kill him for it.

His lawyer, a man named Porter with a smooth voice and a suit that fit better than Harrison's, had already begun shaping the story for the press. Not in the courtroom. Outside it. In the hallway, where the cameras were.

"My client is a dedicated nurse," Porter said to a reporter, while Daniel sat behind him with his head bowed. "He spent his life caring for other people's mothers and grandmothers. He is the victim here."

Melissa heard about it on the small television in the common room, during the hour they were allowed out of their cells. She stood with the other women, watching Daniel's face on the screen, and she felt something cold settle in her stomach.

He was good at this. He had always been good at this. At the nursing home, the families had trusted him because he was calm, because he listened, because he remembered their names. At home, she had trusted him for the same reasons, for years, before the scratching started.

Now he was using that same calm on the world, and the world was believing him.

She turned away from the television before the segment ended. She did not want to see him smile. She had seen that smile in the dark of his cell, in her mind, and she did not need to see it again on a screen.

---

Rebecca Lawson did not remember Daniel's face.

That was the problem, and everyone knew it was the problem.

Harrison went to see her on the third day Melissa was in custody. She was at home, not in the hospital anymore, but she was not well. Her husband answered the door. He looked tired in a way that had nothing to do with sleep. He said Rebecca did not like visitors. He said she did not like going outside. He said she had not left the house since she came home, except to see a doctor, and even then she had held his hand the whole way to the car.

Rebecca sat on the couch with a blanket over her legs, even though the house was warm. She was thinner than Melissa remembered. Her hands shook when she reached for her tea.

"I don't remember his face," she said, before Harrison could ask her anything. "I know that's what you want to know. I don't remember it."

"What do you remember?" Harrison asked, gently.

"An arm," Rebecca said. "I remember an arm. It was a man's arm. It was strong. It came around me from behind, in the parking lot, and then everything went dark. I woke up in the back of a car. I woke up next to a man who was barely breathing. I didn't know who he was. I didn't know who she was. I just knew I was alive, and I didn't know why."

"Do you remember Melissa?" Harrison asked.

Rebecca looked down at her blanket.

"She was the one who brought me to the police," she said. "That's what they told me. She drove me there. She saved me."

"Then why are you afraid to go outside?" Harrison asked.

Rebecca did not answer for a long time. When she did, her voice was very small.

"Because I keep thinking he will find me again," she said. "Or she will. I don't know which one I'm supposed to be afraid of anymore. And that scares me more than anything."

Her husband put a hand on her shoulder. She flinched, just a little, and then she leaned into him, as if she were apologizing for it.

Harrison left his card on the table. He told her to call him if she remembered anything else. He told her she did not have to decide anything yet.

On the drive back, he thought about what she had said, and what she had not said. She could not identify Daniel. She could not clear Melissa. She was a witness who had survived, and that was supposed to be enough, but in a courtroom, survival was not the same as proof.

He needed something else. Something with a date on it. Something with a time on it. Something no one could explain away.

He thought about the photograph.

---

Melissa had not told Harrison everything about the fourteen days.

She had told Miller most of it, in that small office, when she was panicking and trying to make him understand. She had told him she was pretending, that she was playing along so Daniel would not kill her, that she needed him to trust her.

What she had not said, clearly, in a way anyone could use, was why she could not simply leave.

Harrison asked her that on his second visit. He did not ask it the way Miller had asked it, like an accusation. He asked it the way a lawyer asks it, like a man trying to build a wall and finding a hole in it.

"Melissa," he said. "A jury is going to ask you the same thing Miller asked you. You found the closet. You knew what he was. Why did you stay for fourteen days? Why didn't you run?"

She was quiet for a long time. She looked at the wall behind him, at the scuff marks on the paint, at the small, high window that let in a square of gray light.

"I was afraid for my life," she said at last. "And I wanted to make sure I could protect other people's lives. I thought if I left, someone else would get hurt."

Harrison wrote that down, but slowly, and she could see it was not enough. It was vague. It was the kind of answer that sounded true and proved nothing.

"That's what you will tell a jury?" he asked.

"That's what happened," she said.

She did not say anything more. There was something else, underneath, something she did not want to look at too closely. She pushed it away, the way she had pushed the sound away in her cell the night before. If she did not name it, it was not there.

"It doesn't make me innocent," Melissa said, very quietly. "It just makes me someone who was afraid."

Harrison looked at her for a long moment.

"Then we will have to make afraid be enough," he said. "Because it is the only version we can give them."

---

That night, Melissa lay on the narrow bunk and listened to the cell block settle. The crying woman had stopped crying. The guard's keys had gone quiet. The fluorescent light buzzed, and then, very faintly, she heard it again.

Scratching. Behind the wall. Small, patient, deliberate — so faint she almost missed it.

She sat up. Her heart was beating too fast. She put her hand flat against the cold concrete, as if she could feel it through the wall, as if she could tell whether it was real or whether her mind was making it up because she was tired and afraid and alone.

It stopped.

She lay back down. She stared at the ceiling. She thought about Daniel, in his medical unit, calm and believed. She thought about Rebecca, on her couch, afraid to go outside. She thought about Harrison, with his folder, trying to make the truth sound simple.

And she thought about something else, something she had not said out loud yet, something that had been forming in her mind since the courtroom, since the handcuffs, since the moment she understood that Daniel's story was winning.

He loved to talk. He loved to explain himself. He loved an audience. He loved being the smartest man in the room.

He had spent two weeks telling her everything because he thought she admired him. He had flipped the story in the hospital because he thought he could outsmart everyone. He was not afraid of the truth. He was afraid of not getting credit for it.

*Let him have the credit,* she thought. *Let him have all of it, on the stand, in front of everyone.*

She did not know yet how to make that happen. She did not know if Harrison would let her try. She only knew that evidence was not going to save her, because the evidence could be explained away, and a photograph could be called staged, and a necklace could be bought by anybody.

But Daniel's ego could not be explained away. It was the one thing about him that had never changed, not in the nursing home, not in their apartment, not in the hospital, not in custody.

If she could get him on the stand, and make him hear her take credit for everything he had done, he would not be able to stand it.

He would have to correct her.

And when he corrected her, he would tell the truth.

She lay there and rehearsed it in her head, the way she used to rehearse conversations with Daniel before she said them out loud. She would sit in the witness box, calm, certain, and she would tell the jury she had planned it all — the vials, the notes, the parking lot, all of it. She would use his words, the ones he had used with her, the ones he was so proud of, and she would watch his face change as he realized she was taking his work from him in front of everyone. He would not be able to let her keep it. He was not built that way. He had to be the smartest man in the room, and if she took that from him, he would take it back, even if taking it back meant telling them everything.

She did not know if Harrison would let her try it. She did not know if a jury would believe her, even for a moment. She only knew that the evidence was not going to save her, because the evidence could be explained away, and a photograph could be called staged, and a necklace could be bought by anybody.

She closed her eyes. For the first time since the door had closed behind her, she did not dream about the handcuffs, or the courtroom, or the television with her name on it.

She dreamed about a courtroom, too, but a different one. A bigger one. A quieter one. Daniel on the stand, his calm cracking, his voice rising, his hands shaking — not from fear, but from rage — because the woman he had tried to frame was standing in front of a jury and claiming his work as her own.

She woke up just before dawn, to the sound of the guard's keys, and the scratching was gone.

But the plan was still there.

monsterpsychologicalfiction

About the Creator

K-jay

I weave stories from social media,and life, blending critique, fiction, and horror. Inspired by Hamlet, George R.R. Martin, and Stephen King, I craft poetic, layered tales of intrigue and resilience,

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed. You could also become a paid subscriber, letting them know you appreciate their work.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by K-jay