Clayface is the Perfect Origin Story for an Underrated Batman Villain
DC could finally be heading in the right direction with their villain origin films.

This is the third DC story we have gotten through the point of view of a villain, and I think it's one of the best movies we have gotten this year. Horror has truly been on a whole other level, and we got one of the most unique body horror films for 2026. Clayface was one of my most anticipated horror films this year, and I was left vastly entertained by the origin story of how one man became one of Batman's most dangerous villains.
Clayface follows the story of a rising actor named Matt Hagen, who has finally made it to the spotlight. Matt came from nothing in Gotham City, but through sheer willpower and determination, he made a name for himself. Things appear to be going very smoothly for Matt, once he discovers that he has been nominated for an Oscar...but as the saying goes for all the Batman villains, all it takes is one bad day to break someone.
Matt Hagen and his best friend, Corey, who is also trying to make it in the acting world, go out to celebrate Matt's victory at a club. Matt catches the attention of a beautiful young woman named Mia, and he begins to dance with her at the club. Corey attempts to warn Matt that Mia is the girlfriend of a powerful and corrupt gang leader named Szabo, but Matt ignores this threat, wanting to spend time with Mia.
He later awakens to find men surrounding him in his bedroom, and Mia leaves with her boyfriend, Szabo. He then orders his men to hold down Matt as he cuts into his face, permanently scarring him. This outcome leads to the gang trying to tarnish his name with a fake assault story against Mia, and even though Matt tries to go against Szabo through the justice system, he ends up losing the case through typical Gotham corruption. He attempts to fix his face through constructive surgery, but it doesn't bode well in the end. He loses his acting career, and this blow leads to his isolation, locking himself away from his friends and the acting world.
He loses his money through the justice system and trying to fix his face, leading to the outcome of moving to the poor area of Gotham.
Matt becomes desperate to fix his face, and finds the cure through a random scientist he discovers through a magazine.

A woman named Caitlyn Corr was responsible for creating a possible cure for people who receive brutal injuries to their body. She had created her own regenerative system, but her work had led to people betraying her for their own personal gain. She offers Matt a chance to fix his face, and after a long period of time, Matt is eventually given his face back. She warns him to stay out of the Hollywood spotlight for now, to see if any more tests need to be run for his face. Matt doesn't listen, and decides to make a surprise appearance at a premiere of a show that he had been kicked out of when his face was scarred.
He greets his agent, and while Matt is confronting her over being replaced with another actor for the movie role he was meant for, his face begins to droop. He panics, and runs back to Caitlyn's lab, begging for help. He injects himself with a huge amount of the special serum she used to cure Matt's face, and he claims to Caityln that he now feels great.
Nothing happens for a while, and things seem to be looking up for Matt again. He is slowly returning to the acting world, and he is now living his life outside of Hollywood, having a good time. Then he accidentally injures himself one day while playing a game of basketball with a group of people, and he demonstrates this new discovery to Caitlynn, who gets a bad feeling about this. She tells Matt they must keep this a secret for now, in case this discovery will lead to bad outcomes for both of them.
While on a plane ride, Matt watches a news report on Szabo and his gang, and during the footage, he learns that Frank, his former manager, had been working with Mia and Szabo. Matt suddenly experiences an extreme moment of body horror through his eyes, and while attempting to remove the skin covering his eyes, he resorts to putting on sunglasses to cover up this deformity for now. He shows up to Caitlyn's house, and she comforts him, by holding his hand, and he instantly goes back to normal. Matt realizes that he is in love with her, and before they can share a possible romantic moment, Caitlyn's fiancé walks in, named John, who is investigating Szabo's case against Matt.
Matt leaves their place, and later on, Caitlynn continues her experiments with Matt, wanting to know how he was able to change his appearance on the plane. She learns that his hatred for the gang who ruined his life is the cause of this, and he can now shapeshift into people, including Frank and Caitlyn, while he was sleeping.
Despite this concerning new ability, this doesn't stop Matt from confronting the people who wronged him.

Matt Hagen decides to confront Frank, and he admits to going against Matt, and even his best friend, Corey, wronged him as well. Matt snaps, and kills Frank, going as far to impersonate him to avoid being detected. He then confronts Corey, who has now made it to the Hollywood world like Matt once did. Corey admits to betraying him, due to Szabo threatening him, and he had no choice but to give in, including taking an acting job, because he was scared to even reject this opportunity. Matt comforts Corey, but uses a hug to trick him, and suffocates him with his own body.
He impersonates Corey, and proceeds to enter the set for Corey's movie, to confront his co - star, Mia, who also betrayed him in the beginning of the movie. Matt gives Mia the kiss of death, and runs away, leading to the police investigation getting stronger and more confusing. John is determined to solve the case, even going as far to threaten Szabo, who is growing concerned with the targets being connected to him.
Matt struggles to get over the murder of Corey, and he experiences body horror transformations over his anger and guilt. Caitlyn comes over to his place to comfort him, and he resorts back to his original form. Matt confesses his love for her, but she rejects him, not wanting to betray John. She leaves, and while Matt is sadly watching her leave his place, he spots a random guy following her.
Szabo decides to set his eyes on Caitlyn, and Matt realizes he must protect her from harm. This man follows Caitlyn for a long time, and when he proceeds to threaten her, we get a crazy reveal that this is actually Matt, who impersonated her. Matt kills this man, and copies his appearance, determined to take down Szabo and his men.
Matt Hagen welcomes his new era as a future Batman villain.

This is the best sequence of the entire film. Matt Hagen enters Szabo's club disguised as one of his men, and we get a very entertaining scene with Hagen fully embracing his role as a villain. He playfully messes with Szabo and his men, playing with his prey before going for the kill. He impersonates multiple people to trick his enemies, while having a good time in their club at the same time. He disposes each of the men, then breaks into Szabo's main lair, killing both Mia and Szabo.
John goes over to the club to investigate the very brutal crime scene, and he goes over to speak with Matt, who denies having nothing to do with deaths of this gang. Caitlyn realizes that Matt is indeed very dangerous and responsible for the murders. She goes over to her place to speak with John, and she ends up discovering the dead body of her fiancé. Matt was pretending to be John, and believes in his delusional state of mind, that Caitlyn loves him too. Caitlyn panics and uses a taser on him, causing Matt to fall out of a window. Matt fully becomes Clayface, and Caitlyn has no choice but to terminate Matt, killing the regenerative cells within his body, something that she had once warned Matt about if things got out of hand with the process of curing him.
His body sinks into the sewer, and Matt Hagen is presumed dead.
Caitlynn has officially abandoned her research, and she wanders Gotham City, becoming paranoid of possibly running into Hagen, disguised as a random citizen. She bumps into a homeless man, and she offers him a dollar. He thanks her, and walks away, going deep into the sewer. This turns out to be Matt in disguise, and he uses his powers to conjure up Caitlyn, pretending that she is confessing his love for him.
Matt transforms into Clayface again, and the film ends with Matt roaring in anger.
Clayface is exactly what the DC universe needs to focus on. We need more DC villain origins stories like this. Following a particular pattern for their universe would make them stand out from Marvel, who is currently stuck in a loophole of creating superhero film after superhero film, that is quickly becoming tedious.
DC has a huge advantage here, and Clayface is another triumph of a DC origin story.
Clayface is one of the best DC films ever made, and I hope we get to see this character again in a future DC project!
Thank you for reading!
Emy Quinn
About the Creator
Emy Quinn
Horror Enthusiast. I love to learn about the history of horror, I write about all kinds of horror topics, and I love to write short horror stories!
Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.
Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.
Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.