Geeks logo

Unwrapping the Masterpiece Inside Chitty Chitty Bang Bang

We need to re-edit the film for the next generation.

By Elliott J. SchuchardtPublished 6 days ago • 4 min read
Unwrapping the Masterpiece Inside Chitty Chitty Bang Bang
Photo by Bruce Warrington on Unsplash

Next month, on December 13, 2026, actor Dick Van Dyke celebrates his 101st birthday. The comedian's upcoming milestone provides the opportunity to revisit Dick Van Dyke's most misunderstood vehicle: the 1968 musical fantasy Chitty Chitty Bang Bang. Nearly sixty years after its release, the film endures as a beloved childhood staple, yet watching it with adult eyes reveals a fascinating cinematic paradox. Chitty Chitty Bang Bang is a genuinely great movie trapped inside a bloated, unfocused bad one.

To understand why the film feels so wildly uneven, one has to look at its origins. In the mid-1960s, producer Albert R. Broccoli —fresh off the James Bond box-office juggernaut—decided to adapt Fleming’s sole children’s book. Broccoli wasn't just making a kids' movie; he was openly attempting to bottle the lightning of Walt Disney’s 1964 smash Mary Poppins. He spared no expense in assembling the exact creative DNA that made Poppins a phenomenon. He lured Van Dyke back to England with a massive paycheck after the actor initially balked at the script's plot holes. He hired the Oscar-winning songwriting duo Richard and Robert Sherman, brought on Poppins music supervisor Irwin Kostal, and recruited choreographers Marc Breaux and Dee Dee Wood. Even the setting—an idyllic, sun-dappled Edwardian England—was designed to mirror the whimsical charm of Cherry Tree Lane.

For its first half, Broccoli’s gamble pays off handsomely. The movie inside Chitty Chitty Bang Bang that works is a warm, breezy, delightfully eccentric British family musical. Van Dyke is in peak form as Caractacus Potts, a widowed, absent-minded inventor raising two bright children, Jeremy and Jemima, alongside his gloriously batty father, Grandpa. When Truly Scrumptious—played with luminous grace by Sally Ann Howes—crashes into their lives, the film sparks with genuine romantic chemistry and infectious joy. The Sherman Brothers' songs in this first act are largely top-tier, propelled by Van Dyke’s effortless athleticism in "Me Ol’ Bamboo" and the buoyant optimism of the title track. Even later in the film, the delightful "Doll on a Music Box" sequence showcases the leads' wonderful theatrical charm. At its core, the best version of the movie has a clear, grounded heart: a struggling father trying to make his kids happy while opening his heart to love again.

Unfortunately, at a staggering 145 minutes, the film doesn't know when to stop. Co-written by director Ken Hughes and children’s author Roald Dahl, the screenplay eventually abandons its brisk pacing and domestic anchor for a sprawling, tonal mess. Once Caractacus begins telling a seaside story about the fictional, child-hating barony of Vulgaria, the movie spirals into an overstuffed second half that feels like an entirely different, far inferior picture. Worse yet, the revelation that the entire Vulgarian adventure is merely a bedtime story robs the climax of real stakes.

Hidden beneath all that excess, however, is a tight, magical 100-minute classic. With a few surgical cuts, Chitty Chitty Bang Bang could easily be rescued from its own bloat:

  • Cut Sally Ann Howes’ solo, "Lovely Lonely Man." While Howes possesses a gorgeous soprano voice, this syrupy ballad brings the breezy first act to a screeching halt. Watching Truly wander around the Potts estate singing slowly about her budding feelings for Caractacus feels like an obligatory, old-fashioned pacing killer. Their chemistry is already crystal clear through their playful banter, making this sluggish number completely unnecessary.

  • Eliminate the "Roses of Success" sequence. Roughly halfway through the film, Grandpa is kidnapped and flown to Vulgaria, where he is locked in a dungeon with a group of elderly scientists. This triggers "Roses of Success," a repetitive musical number that grinds the narrative momentum down just as the adventure should be ramping up. While Lionel Jeffries is wonderful as Grandpa, watching a room full of old men sing about failure adds nothing to the plot and pads an already swollen runtime.

  • Eliminate the Baron and Baroness’s slapstick routines. Gert Fröbe and Anna Quayle play the infantile rulers of Vulgaria, Baron and Baroness Bomburst. While their childish antics provide a few chuckles, their extended scenes—including the drawn-out "Chu-Chi Face" number and the Baron’s repeated, Wile E. Coyote-style assassination attempts on his wife—quickly wear out their welcome. Cutting their screen time in half would keep the villains menacing rather than exhausting.

  • Drop the "it was all a story" framing device. The biggest structural flaw in the script is revealing that the trip to Vulgaria was just a tale Caractacus spun on the beach. By simply letting the car actually fly the family to Vulgaria—and keeping the terrifying, iconic Child Catcher as a real threat rather than a fictional figment—the second half regains the genuine magic it so desperately needs.

As Dick Van Dyke prepares to blow out 101 candles next month, his legacy as an entertainer who brought boundless joy to the screen is unmatched. Chitty Chitty Bang Bang may never have achieved the seamless perfection of Mary Poppins, largely because its creators mistook bigger for better. Yet even wrapped in an overlong, messy outer shell, the film’s beating heart—powered by Van Dyke’s timeless charm and a magical flying car—still manages to soar.

___________

Elliott J. Schuchardt is the author of America's Achilles Heel: How to Protect Your Family When America Loses the Reserve Currency. In 2026, Schuchardt was a candidate for the Tennessee General Assembly.

celebritiesentertainmentcomedymovie

About the Creator

Elliott J. Schuchardt

Elliott Schuchardt is the author of America's Achilles Heel: How to Protect Your Family When America Loses the Reserve Currency. Schuchardt was a candidate for the Tennessee General Assembly in the August 2026 primary. Follow my blog.

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Elliott J. Schuchardt