Sunrise on the Reaping: A Sanitized Version of Haymitch Abernathy's Memories
Minor spoilers ahead for Sunrise on the Reaping, the much-awaited Hunger Games film bringing everyone's favorite alcoholic rascal, Haymitch Abernathy, back to the big screen.

Sunrise on the Reaping is receiving plenty of rave reviews, with critics lauding it as one of the best installments in The Hunger Games franchise. Never mind the one particularly sour review from The Guardian, which seems to regard the film as an unnecessary addition to the franchise. I would have to agree with the more favorable assessments, although I wouldn't necessarily call it the best Hunger Games film.
Before getting into why, it is worth remembering what this story represents.
Sunrise on the Reaping takes us back to the Second Quarter Quell, 40 years after the events of The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes. It follows Haymitch Abernathy, District 12's sole victor in the 50th Hunger Games, and the events that would eventually turn him into the person we meet in the original trilogy.
The film opens on Reaping Day, which also happens to be Haymitch's birthday. There is something particularly poignant about the idea that there will always be a sunrise on Reaping Day, especially when Haymitch believes that the two events will forever coincide. It is Lenore Dove, his love, who challenges that certainty. One day, she tells him, there will be a sunrise on his birthday that will not be accompanied by a Reaping.
And she is right. It simply takes another 25 years or so, for that day to arrive.
It is a beautiful reminder that tomorrow is never guaranteed to look like today. The circumstances we have come to accept as permanent can change, even when we cannot imagine how.
A Cast Worth Watching
The performances are among the film's strongest elements, even when some of the characters are given considerably less screen time than they deserved.
McKenna Grace as Maysilee Donner is such a delight to watch. Despite having limited time on screen, she brings a great deal of personality to the character. I would have loved to see more of her, particularly because the film leaves out some of the smaller interactions that made Maysilee so endearing in the novel.
And then there is Glenn Close as Drusilla Sickle.
She was Drusilla Sickle in the flesh. Absolutely glorious, and someone I would never want to be in the same room with. She is infuriating, insufferable, and precisely the kind of character you would love to slap (we were all Maysilee!). Close understood the assignment, and I genuinely wish we had been given more scenes with her. She is easily one of the film's highlights.
Kieran Culkin as Caesar Flickerman is another performance worth discussing. He may not have the extravagant colors and flamboyance associated with the Caesar Flickerman we see during the 75th Hunger Games, but I suspect that was a deliberate choice by the filmmakers. This younger Caesar gives us a glimpse of the person behind the televised persona, particularly in the moments when he interacts with the tributes away from the cameras.
His repeated emphasis on the word "kids" is especially telling. He reminds the tributes that they are children (but he doesn't care), and we see him acknowledge the tears and distress that make for bad television. Culkin plays these moments masterfully. There is something almost disarming about seeing this side of Caesar, because we now know exactly that Caesar is a terrible person. He is not a Capitol figure in the same vein as Effie Trinket, whose relationship with the Games and the people involved can be understood differently as the franchise progresses. Caesar loves the spectacle. He lives for the Games, believes they are necessary, and shares the Capitol's prevailing attitude toward the tributes. He may call them kids, but that does not mean he sees them as human beings deserving of dignity or protection. To him, they are part of the spectacle, much like they are to Drusilla and so many others in the Capitol.
Culkin makes that contradiction fascinating to watch. He gives us a Caesar who can recognize that the tributes are children while still participating enthusiastically in the machinery that treats them as disposable.
Maya Hawke as Wiress also deserved more screen time. The novel gives us considerably more opportunities to understand her character and appreciate the qualities that make her such a compelling presence in the original trilogy. Wiress is particularly interesting because she is the tribute who never needed to spill blood to win her Games. There is so much more to her than what the film allows us to see.
Lili Taylor as Mags Flanagan, the District 4 victor of the 11th Hunger Games, is another example. She is part of a cast filled with characters whose histories and experiences could have added so much to the film. Yet Mags, like several others, is essentially relegated to the background. We barely get the opportunity to spend meaningful time with her or understand more about the character. Taylor is a welcome addition to the cast, but the film gives her very little room to make Mags memorable.
Joseph Zada, meanwhile, embodies the younger Haymitch Abernathy remarkably well. His performance is masterful, particularly in the way he communicates Haymitch's terror, trauma, and agony. You can feel his distress as he watches children, many of whom have become people he cares about, face the certainty of death in the arena.
What I particularly enjoyed was how Zada captured a younger, jaded and cynical version of the Haymitch we know through Woody Harrelson's portrayal. The resemblance is not simply physical or a matter of mannerisms. He gives us a convincing sense of how this young person could eventually become the Haymitch we meet decades later. It was beautiful to watch, and I cannot wait to see more from him as an actor.
Whitney Peak as Lenore Dove was also brilliant. I wish we had been given considerably more time with her. Her character is central to understanding Haymitch and what he stands to lose, so the limited time we spend with her is particularly disappointing.
Jesse Plemons is admirable in his role as Plutarch Heavensbee, while Elle Fanning makes for a convincing Effie Trinket. Ralph Fiennes, on the other hand, could have carried considerably more weight as President Snow.
I understand that this is not Snow's movie, and that giving him more screen time would have taken away from the characters whose story we are actually following. However, Snow is one of the looming figures of The Hunger Games. His presence should carry a certain gravitas even when he is not at the center of the story. He is someone we know we would never want to be in the same room with.
Unfortunately, because several scenes from the novel that help establish his influence and menace never made it into the film, Fiennes has less material to work with. His portrayal is not necessarily poor, but the character feels less imposing than he should.
Ben Wang as Wyatt Callow was another welcome presence. I wish we had more time with him, too. We see his death in the film, but the emotional impact is considerably weaker than it is in the novel. There is also a difference in how Haymitch experiences this event in the book, where he does not witness Wyatt's death firsthand. The film's treatment of it simply does not deliver the emotional payoff that the character deserves.
And I cannot stress enough how much more we needed of Louella McCoy or her body double Lou Lou.
They are both important characters in the book, and their relationship with the other tributes contributes to some of its most humanizing moments. One particularly devastating omission is the line "You'll murder us!", which both Lou Lou and Haymitch say in the novel. Its absence is another example of how the adaptation removes moments that give the original story its emotional and thematic weight.
What We Lost Along the Way
This is where my disappointment with the adaptation becomes considerably more pronounced.
We lost Maysilee making tokens for the other tributes. We lost Ampert wanting to call Maysilee his sister, we lost too much to mention. These may seem like small details when considered individually, but they are precisely the kinds of interactions that make the characters feel like people rather than pieces being moved around a Hunger Games arena.
The novel gives us time to see the tributes as children who are frightened, vulnerable, and aware that they are facing almost certain death. We see them build relationships, trust one another, and try to hold on to some semblance of dignity and integrity despite the circumstances imposed on them.
We also get to see Maysilee's kindness toward the other tributes. She becomes someone they can approach, someone who can make their circumstances a little more bearable. These interactions help explain why she became so endearing to the people around her, especially when we consider that this is not necessarily how she was perceived back in District 12.
They were not simply District piglets waiting to be slaughtered for the Capitol's entertainment. They were human beings.

There were moments before the Games even began, particularly during training, that helped establish these relationships and made the eventual tragedies so much harder to bear. We spend considerable time with the characters in their apartment, interacting with their fellow tributes and mentors, as well as during the training sessions. These scenes are not merely filler. They give us the opportunity to understand the people who will eventually be forced into the arena together.
And the problem does not end when the Games begin.
We simply did not spend enough time in the arena.
The arena itself was beautiful, and its design was particularly deceptive. It was meant to lull the tributes, and even the audience, into a false sense of comfort. There was something unsettling about the contrast between its inviting appearance and the violence and danger hidden within it. That atmosphere deserved considerably more time to develop.
So much happens inside the arena, and yet the film moves through these events rather quickly. We do not get enough time to appreciate the environment, understand its deceptive nature, or experience the full extent of what the tributes go through. The arena should have been more than a backdrop for the Games. It was an essential part of the story.
I understand that there are limitations to the film format. A novel can spend hundreds of pages developing characters, relationships, and the smallest details of an environment, while a movie has to make difficult decisions about what can realistically fit into its runtime. I also understand that Suzanne Collins had a significant hand in the film's final product, and I have no intention of dismissing that involvement.
Still, I think the narrative could have been handled better.
I would have much preferred a two-part adaptation or, at the very least, a substantially longer theatrical cut. Honestly, this story deserved a four-hour movie. There was enough material to justify that runtime, and it would have given the filmmakers room to develop the characters, relationships, training sequences, and arena events without sacrificing the narrative's momentum.
We need a director's cut. Worldwide. Immediately.

The film is faithful enough to the source material in its broader narrative, but it leaves out so much of what made the book emotionally rich. There is a difference between adapting the events of a story and successfully translating the emotional experience of reading it. I think Sunrise on the Reaping manages the former considerably better than the latter.
A Sanitized Version of Haymitch's Memories

There are scenes in the book that never made it into the film, just as there are moments in the movie that were not part of the original material. Some changes work better than others. Unfortunately, several omissions remove much of the emotional weight that made the novel so devastating.
I choose to see the film as a sanitized version of Haymitch Abernathy's memories, filtered through the mind of a man who has spent years relying on nepenthe to cope with what happened to him.
After returning to District 12, Haymitch loses almost everyone and everything he has ever loved. He becomes the worst victor in the history of the Hunger Games, as he once promised Maysilee Donner he would. The person we eventually meet in the original trilogy is someone who has survived something he can neither properly process nor escape.
Perhaps that is how we should approach this adaptation. Haymitch, much like Katniss, is an unreliable narrator. His memories are not necessarily complete, and the passage of time, trauma, and alcoholism can make the recollection of certain events considerably less reliable.
The film feels like someone remembering the highlights of an experience rather than reliving the entirety of it.
There are also moments of happiness in the movie that were not present in the book. These additions contribute to a version of events that feels considerably more palatable than the story readers encountered on the page.
For viewers who have not read the book, I can understand why the movie works so well. It is entertaining, visually compelling, and perhaps one of the strongest cinematic entries in the franchise. However, I find it difficult to imagine that most people who have been following The Hunger Games closely enough to watch this installment are entirely unfamiliar with the source material.
Readers know what is missing. They know which characters deserved more time, which moments should have carried greater emotional weight, and which events were considerably more devastating in the book.
The Capitol's highlight reel presents Haymitch as cunning and resourceful, but without the full context, his actions can come across as cowardly. The film gives me a similar impression. So much of the story is missing that it almost feels like a Capitol-approved propaganda piece.
That is why I choose to interpret Sunrise on the Reaping as an incomplete recollection of Haymitch's past. We are left wondering what was omitted, what was distorted, and which moments were simply too painful to remember.
There is another point worth making about the book itself. Sunrise on the Reaping was not an easy read. In fact, it was painful. Suzanne Collins does not simply write another installment because there is room for one in the franchise. She writes when she has something to say, and this novel had plenty to say about power, spectacle, dehumanization, and the treatment of children under an authoritarian system.
As a standalone movie, it is an excellent addition to the franchise. It is watchable, entertaining, and carried by some genuinely wonderful performances. It is not a terrible film by any measure. However, compared with the richness and sheer breadth of the novel, it falls short of what it could have been.
I still maintain that The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes is the best Hunger Games film. That adaptation delivered the emotional experience I wanted from a cinematic interpretation of Suzanne Collins's writing. Sunrise on the Reaping has not quite managed the same.
I am sorry, Suzanne Collins, but the book was phenomenal in ways the film simply could not replicate. And while I appreciate what the filmmakers have given us, I cannot help thinking about everything we could have had.
I'll say it again: We need a director's cut. Worldwide. Immediately.
Seven out of ten stars.
About the Creator
Karina Thyra
Fangirl of sorts.
Twitter: @ArianaGsparks
Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.
Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.
Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.