Geeks logo

I Play Rocky: Movie Review

a remarkable story that deserved a better film

By Maria LPublished about 13 hours ago • 3 min read

Whoever first suggested that there should be awards for the best movie trailers was definitely onto something, because a really good trailer has the ability to make any film seem like a potential masterpiece. That's exactly what happened to me with I Play Rocky. Every time the trailer played before a movie at the cinema, I found myself watching it with the same level of enthusiasm. It was brilliantly edited and did an exceptional job of selling the story it was trying to tell. By the time I eventually got around to watching the film, my expectations were understandably quite high.

The story of Sylvester Stallone is one of the most extraordinary underdog stories we've ever seen in Hollywood. We're talking about a man who was once so broke that he had to sell his own dog, his best friend, simply because he couldn't afford to buy food. A man who went from sleeping on the streets and struggling to make ends meet, to eventually becoming one of the biggest movie stars in the world. Stallone quite literally wrote his own success story, refusing to give up on his ambitions even when seemingly everyone around him had already written him off. So, when you have material like this to work with, particularly when telling the story behind the making of Rocky, you're starting with something pretty special.

For the most part, I Play Rocky is a perfectly enjoyable watch, and there are certainly things to appreciate about it. However, I couldn't help feeling that it never quite reaches the emotional heights that a story like this deserves. This is Sylvester Stallone we're talking about. His journey is one that should leave you feeling inspired and emotional by the time the credits roll. Instead, I found myself surprisingly disconnected from much of what was unfolding on screen. It's not that the film is particularly bad or that it doesn't have its moments, but there's a certain lack of sentiment throughout that makes it difficult to become as invested as I wanted to be. I went into this expecting to feel everything, and unfortunately, I came away feeling very little.

On the acting front, there are a couple of performances that really stand out, particularly P.J. Byrne and Jay Duplass, who are both excellent. Anthony Ippolito is a much more complicated one to judge. There are moments where it genuinely feels like you're watching the real Stallone, and he manages to capture his look, mannerisms and presence in a way that's quite remarkable. Other times, however, it feels as though he's playing Stallone as Rocky, rather than the man himself. Stallone in real life doesn't speak as slowly or with quite the same exaggerated drawl as his most famous character, and he's considerably more articulate and sharp than the portrayal sometimes suggests. As a result, the performance occasionally borders on parody, making it difficult to know exactly what to make of it. It's an interesting portrayal, and one that certainly has its moments, even if I wasn't entirely convinced by it throughout.

There's also the rather bizarre fact that Sylvester Stallone himself had no direct involvement in the making of this movie. When you're making a film about a real-life person who is still very much alive, you'd think having them involved in the production would be something of a priority. Stallone didn't write, direct, produce or formally participate in the making of the film, although he did speak with Anthony Ippolito over Zoom, so it's not as though he's completely opposed to the project. Still, given how personal and significant this story is to Stallone, I find it strange that he wasn't more closely involved in its retelling.

Ultimately, I Play Rocky feels like one of those classic cases of what could have been. There's an extraordinary story here, one with all the ingredients to make for a genuinely moving and inspiring film, and I just wish the finished product had managed to capture more of that magic. It's a perfectly okay movie, and I certainly don't regret watching it, but when you're dealing with a story as remarkable as Sylvester Stallone's, it's hard not to wish that someone had managed to get a little more out of it.

celebritiespop culturereviewmovie

About the Creator

Maria L

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed. You could also become a paid subscriber, letting them know you appreciate their work.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Maria L