Futurism logo

Your AI Note Taker Is a Legal Time Bomb. Lawyers Are Kicking It Out of Meetings

Executives love AI bots that transcribe every word. Corporate attorneys say those transcripts could waive attorney-client privilege and get you sued

By Behind the TechPublished 7 months ago • 2 min read

You are reading the DealBook newsletter And if you are in a virtual meeting right now check the participant list Jeffrey Gifford does He is a lawyer in San Antonio who handles corporate governance and M and A at Dykema Before meetings start he plays bouncer When I see that A I note taker pop up I will just say Hey Mike Jim Barbara I am going to turn it off and kick it out of the meeting Gifford told DealBook This happens constantly Everybody and their mother is using these things he said Executives Boards Nonexecutive businesspeople Skipping meetings and sending an A I note taker instead has been called the latest office power move To lawyers it is a ticking legal risk Every Joke Is Now Discoverable A I generated transcripts capture everything Offhand comments Quickly corrected statements Jokes Things humans would never put in official minutes And they show up in meetings that would not otherwise be recorded In a lawsuit or investigation every word becomes discoverable Even worse Sharing the meeting with an A I bot may void attorney client privilege If a third party company has access to the transcript courts may decide your legal strategy is no longer protected The New York City Bar Association issued a formal opinion last year warning lawyers to consider whether recording is tactically well advised One concern is accuracy An A I could record does matter as does not matter Try explaining that mistake in court years later Not Only Accurate But With the Right Emphasis Corporate lawyers also worry about context Board minutes are crafted carefully You want to make sure that the minutes if they get into a courtroom are going to not only be accurate but also are going to have the emphasis that the board would like said Doug Raymond a partner at Faegre Drinker Biddle and Reath The worst case scenarios write themselves An executive talking through an acquisition says it will help the company dominate the category That lands in an antitrust case A board member casually acknowledges a risk Shareholders cite it in a lawsuit Typically private litigation asks for all documents and communications related to a particular topic said Christoffer Lee a lawyer at Pillsbury He expects regulators to start asking specifically for A I transcriptions You are just having to potentially address extraneous stuff that you otherwise would not have Gifford said Does a Bot Break Privilege Executives expect conversations with legal counsel to stay privileged That protection disappears if you share the info with outsiders An A I note taker might count as an outsider Courts have not ruled directly yet but the signals are mixed In February Judge Jed S Rakoff ruled that Claude A I transcripts were not protected because the user had no expectation of privacy Another judge ruled ChatGPT transcripts could not be compelled A I note taking represents the next frontier Lee said They Are Not Fessing Up Raymond says clients got the message fast Initially I was seeing and hearing about it a lot like Oh this is great Now I do not have to worry about writing my corporate minutes But I think people have realized pretty quickly that it is a bad idea Now he says if they are doing it they are not fessing up The productivity hack is tempting The legal exposure is real And as AI bots join more meetings lawyers are left with one job kick them out before the recording starts Do you use AI note takers at work Has your legal team banned them Share your policy in the comments

artificial intelligencetech

About the Creator

Behind the Tech

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Behind the Tech