Steven Soderbergh Uses Meta AI for 10 Percent of Lennon Documentary Sparking Debate on AI in Film
Director says transparency and necessity guide his use while critics call the AI segments banal at Cannes premiere

Read Time 6 minutes Tags AI in Filmmaking Generative AI Steven Soderbergh John Lennon Documentary Ethics Transparency AI Ethics Meta AI CANNES France The day John Lennon was shot on Dec 8 1980 he and Yoko Ono gave an interview to a San Francisco radio crew from their home in New York s Dakota Apartments They were promoting their new album Double Fantasy but the two hour conversation was wide ranging Though the interviewers had been warned no Beatles questions Lennon and Ono were thrillingly open That day Annie Leibovitz also shot the famous portrait of a clothes less Lennon wrapped around Ono The interview is similarly naked The two particularly Lennon riff on love their relationship creativity life after the Beatles raising their toddler son writing songs in bed and much more At the age of 40 Lennon sounds like someone who has found real clarity I feel like nothing happened before today said Lennon In John Lennon The Last Interview Steven Soderbergh turns those surviving tapes into a documentary that does as much to demystify Lennon and Ono as Get Back did to the Beatles The film debuted Saturday at the Cannes Film Festival I was just so compelled by their generosity of spirit throughout the conversation Soderbergh explained in an interview Saturday in Cannes It s like the world took place in one day in this apartment Making it posed an acute problem Soderbergh was resolved to let the audio play He could find ways to visualize much of the film but that still left a large gap where the conversation grows more philosophical I worked on everything that could be solved except that for as long as I could Soderbergh says Then there was the inevitable moment of OK but really what are we going to do We just started playing and ran out of time and money That s where the Meta piece came in Soderbergh accepted an offer to use Meta s artificial intelligence software to conjure surreal imagery for those sections which make up about 10 percent of the film When Soderbergh let the news out earlier this year it prompted an uproar One of America s leading filmmakers was using AI In a film about a Beatle no less The AI parts overwhelmingly slammed by critics in Cannes are fairly banal and don t differ greatly from special effects there are no deepfakes of Lennon But they put Soderberg at the forefront of an industrywide debate about the uses of AI in moviemaking It s a conversation the director who has made movies on iPhones is eager to have AP At a time when AI in film is under much debate you ve been very forthright about your use of it here Why SODERBERGH Transparency is so important in the world outside of the creative context we re not aware of the extent that this is being used and used to manipulate us We don t know because they re not telling We find out after by accident by some whistle blower I m like my own whistle blower This is what he s doing AP Did you expect such a strong response SODERBERGH I knew what was coming I take it very seriously and I understand why people have an emotional response to this subject As I ve said before I feel like I owe people the best version of whatever art I m trying to make and total transparency about how I m doing it But yeah you don t say yes to Meta offering you these tools and offering to finish the film and not know you re going to come in for some heat That was part of the deal AP Some fear generative AI will tear apart the film industry You don t see it as a bogeyman though SODERBERGH I think most jobs that matter when you re making a movie cannot be performed by this tech and never will be performed by this tech As it becomes possible for anybody to create something that meets a certain standard of technical perfection then imperfection becomes more valuable and more interesting We haven t seen yet someone with a certain amount of creative credibility go full metal AI on something and see how people react I think it s necessary How do you know where the line is until somebody crosses it I don t think what I m doing crosses it Some people may disagree I don t know where my line is yet I m waiting to see AP What kind of prompts did you give the program to create the animations SODERBERGH Circles of light that come out of nowhere things like that A black rose that turns into a Busby Berkeley thing and then a red rose I wasn t very articulate to the people I was working with It was hard to describe the things I wanted to see The good part about this technology was at least ability to have something in front of me quickly that I could respond to AP Did your experience give you any kind of framework that you think this technology should be limited to SODERBERGH I ve determined my rule is It has to be necessary Is it the only way to accomplish what I want to see Is it truly the best way to do it That s the real question You re going to see a lot of people doing stuff with AI that fail those two challenges AP There s the ethical debate but also an aesthetic one This is otherwise a naked human dialogue SODERBERGH I needed a way to follow them in flight visually or I m not doing my job It s hard to judge how long it will take us to find homeostasis with this technology I think we will Just looking at this technology in the movie making business each department has or will have a very different relationship with it I ll have a different relationship than a writer than an actor than the costume designer the production designer the sound effects people Each creative person is going to have their own prism and be affected by it in different ways Our inherent desire to have a simple template for how this is to be approached is part of the problem I don t think that s possible I don t think there s a one size fits all AP Regardless the conversation in the film is deeply inspiring SODERBERGH Especially his burning desire to destroy the male rock star myth at a time when that was not the mood anyone else was in That s inspiring What I hope young people who see it get out of it is This guy told the truth about everything from the jump right up through the last day of his life He just was built that way And he was constructive He was very opinionated but also very thoughtful and all in the aid of Can we do this better Can we do a better version of human beings on this planet Why this matters for the industry One Transparency as a stance Soderbergh is disclosing AI use upfront rather than hiding it This contrasts with how many productions use AI tools quietly for de aging cleanup and background generation His argument is that audiences deserve to know when AI shapes what they see Two Scope and role of AI In this case AI handles abstract visual accompaniment for audio where no footage exists It does not replace actors replace performances or generate dialogue The distinction matters for labor and consent debates Three Aesthetic function versus cost cutting Soderbergh frames the use as necessary for visual storytelling not as a way to reduce crew or budget He argues that if AI cannot meet a necessity test it should not be used Four Industry signal High profile directors experimenting publicly set norms Younger filmmakers watch how Cannes and critics react to determine what is acceptable in festivals and distribution Limits and risks One Creative credibility gap Critics at Cannes called the AI segments banal suggesting that the technology did not add artistic value Using AI without clear intent risks breaking audience trust Two Precedent for deeper use Soderbergh says he does not know where his line is yet This openness signals that future projects could push further into generative video voice synthesis or performance augmentation Three Labor concerns Even limited use raises questions for visual effects animators and designers about where work will be displaced The argument that AI cannot do most jobs that matter will be tested as models improve Four Meta partnership optics Accepting tools and finishing from Meta creates perception of corporate influence in creative choices That amplifies backlash regardless of how minimal the AI role is What filmmakers are likely to take away One Define necessity before experimenting Write down what problem AI solves and whether alternatives exist If the answer is no alternatives then document that decision Two Keep AI in service of human performance Avoid deepfakes of living people and avoid generating new dialogue for historical figures without explicit consent and context Three Separate process from product Let audiences see the method through credits making of features and direct statements Soderbergh s whistle blower framing is an example Four Expect category specific norms Cinematographers editors sound designers and writers will each develop different relationships with AI A single industry rule will not hold The broader debate One AI as tool versus author The film community is split between viewing AI as another tool like color grading and viewing it as a shift that undermines authorship Soderbergh lands closer to tool but acknowledges the line is unclear Two Value of imperfection As technical perfection becomes trivial human flaws and choices may become the differentiator This could shift taste toward work that shows human decision making even if it is messier Three Consent and estate issues Using AI for historical figures is less legally fraught than for living actors but still raises questions about legacy and representation The Lennon estate s cooperation likely reduced risk here For audiences the question is whether disclosure changes reception If viewers know 10 percent of visuals are AI generated does it alter how they engage with the dialogue If the answer is yes then transparency is not just ethical it is essential for trust Do you think filmmakers should disclose all AI use in credits or does that overstate the role of minor visual effects Share your view in the comments
About the Creator
Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.
Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.
Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.