Elon Musk OpenAI Trial Goes to Jury After Closing Arguments Focus on Trust Contract and Power
Musk seeks 150 billion dollars and removal of Altman claiming OpenAI abandoned nonprofit mission while OpenAI calls suit sour grapes over lost control

Read Time 6 minutes Tags OpenAI Elon Musk Sam Altman Trial AI Governance Nonprofit For Profit Microsoft After nearly three weeks of testimony the federal trial pitting Elon Musk against OpenAI went to the jury on May 14 2026 in Oakland California The nine member jury will decide whether Sam Altman and Greg Brockman stole a charity when they took investments from Microsoft and turned a nonprofit lab into a for profit powerhouse or whether Musk has a case of sour grapes because he left before OpenAI succeeded The outcome could cripple OpenAI and alter the tech industry landscape What Musk is asking for One Claims and relief Musk sued OpenAI two years ago claiming it strayed from its founding agreement to be a nonprofit lab dedicated to safe AI for the benefit of humanity He is asking for 150 billion dollars in damages and wants Altman kicked off OpenAI board of directors He also wants to unwind OpenAI move to become a for profit company ahead of a potential IPO this year Microsoft was added as a defendant because of 13 billion dollars it has invested in OpenAI Two Legal burden Musk legal team must show that he brought the suit within the statute of limitations For the breach of agreement claim the deadline is three years meaning Musk had to prove he had no way of knowing about a breach before August 5 2021 For the claim that Altman and Brockman enriched themselves the deadline is August 5 2022 For the claim against Microsoft the deadline is four months after that Musk lawyers focused heavily on events of 2023 after OpenAI released ChatGPT Microsoft invested an additional 10 billion dollars in January 2023 and the OpenAI board briefly fired Altman in November 2023 before reinstating him five days later Closing arguments and key evidence One Musk side Steve Molo Musk lead lawyer spent two hours disparaging Altman and Brockman and accusing them of stealing a charity He used the metaphor of a bridge built on Sam Altman version of the truth to question Altman credibility Molo argued that OpenAI breached the terms of the charitable trust by failing to open source its technology and by prioritizing profit over mission He pointed to an October 20 2022 text from Musk to Altman linking to a news article about Microsoft investing 10 billion dollars as the moment Musk realized the breach occurred He also showed emails and proposals from 2017 and 2018 where Musk tried to fold OpenAI into Tesla and proposed a for profit structure that would have given Musk 50 percent of the company while Altman and Brockman received 7 5 percent each Two OpenAI side Sarah Eddy and William Savitt OpenAI lawyers argued that Musk never cared about the nonprofit structure and that what he cared about was winning Eddy said Musk tried multiple times to transform OpenAI into a for profit venture and sought control Savitt said the charity is still alive and that thanks to OpenAI growth its assets are worth more than 200 billion dollars He argued that all funds Musk donated were spent by 2020 so there was nothing left to misuse later He also said Musk left OpenAI for dead in early 2018 and that OpenAI only moved forward because it raised money from other sources Savitt dismissed the events of late 2023 as personality conflicts not safety issues and said they have nothing to do with Musk claims Three Microsoft role Microsoft lead counsel Russell Cohen argued that Microsoft should not be part of the case Microsoft invested in OpenAI between 2019 and 2023 with board approval and Musk never told Microsoft about any conditions on those investments Cohen said Musk publicly tweeted in 2020 that OpenAI was essentially captured by Microsoft showing he knew about the relationship well before filing suit Why the case matters One Precedent for AI governance The case tests whether informal agreements and expectations made during a nonprofit founding can be enforced years later when the organization becomes a commercial success If Musk prevails it could create legal risk for other AI labs that transition from nonprofit to for profit structures Two Control of AGI The dispute is partly about control of artificial general intelligence Eddy said Musk wanted dominion over AGI and wanted to pass control to his children when he dies The jury must decide whether that motivation undermines his claims about mission betrayal Three Evidence problem Musk suit did not cite a single contract or founding document because no such document is believed to exist The case relies on emails text messages and recollections from 2015 to 2018 This makes it a he said she said dispute that turns on witness credibility Procedural notes One Jury role The jury is acting in an advisory role to Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers However the jury decides it will be up to the judge to decide remedies The judge could award damages well below 150 billion dollars or toss out the jury decision and rule that OpenAI did nothing wrong Two Timing The jury begins deliberations on Monday after a break on Friday Judge Rogers will hold a separate hearing with lawyers to determine potential penalties if liability is found Three Public interest The trial has drawn attention because it involves three of the most influential figures in AI and because it addresses unresolved questions about how to structure labs that develop powerful AI systems Broader implications One Impact on OpenAI A loss could force OpenAI to restructure again or pay significant damages A win strengthens its legal position as it prepares for a potential IPO Two Signal to investors and founders The case highlights the risks of ambiguous founding agreements and the importance of documenting mission constraints when raising capital Three Public perception Musk framing of the case as protecting humanity against profit driven drift resonates with critics of AI commercialization OpenAI framing of the case as sour grapes resonates with those who see the lawsuit as an attempt to regain control For the AI industry the verdict will influence how labs balance mission and capital raising For Musk it is a test of whether he can claw back influence over a company he helped create For Altman and Brockman it is a test of whether their pivot to for profit was legally defensible Do you think the lack of a written founding agreement makes Musk case unwinnable or does the conduct of the parties speak louder than the paperwork Share your view in the comments
About the Creator
Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.
Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.
Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.