Futurism logo

Conflicting Theories

Communication verses connection

By Fatal SerendipityPublished 19 days ago • 13 min read
Conflicting Theories
Photo by Saif71.com on Unsplash

The living room was nearly black, except for two squares of morning light through the closed shades. Andi stood in one with a yellow mug warming her hands while Mitch lay on the couch in yesterday’s clothes, a white shawl over him.

She glanced toward the window and flinched, glad the shades were drawn. She couldn’t look at Miriam’s house, or worse, the front yard.

In the garage she shut the door before turning on the light. Mitch’s pickup was packed to the roof with groceries and supplies, and she checked them anyway. When she pulled out her phone, the screen stayed empty, as it had for eight days, but she kept trying.

Back inside, Mitch was folding the shawl.

“Sorry. Did I wake you?”

“No, it’s about time I got up. We need to get moving.”

He reached for his boots. The Idaho woods had weathered him into something handsomer than the city ever had.

“Mitch?”

He looked up.

“Thank you for coming when I called, and for taking care of everything.” She nodded toward Miriam’s house.

“We do what we have to do.”

Eight days earlier, Andi had crossed campus through a commotion she noticed only at the office.

“Do you have service?” Katie asked while Demi and Susanna stared at their phones.

“No. Is the internet out too?”

“Probably an outage,” Susanna said.

Ryan walked in. “The president was just on TV. He says it’s a terrorist attack.”

“Dan heard it’s worldwide,” Demi said. “I think the radio still works.”

Katie frowned. “That’s a pretty big terrorist attack.”

Everyone agreed it would come back, so Andi left early, before the gas stations were overrun. By evening the news said every cell network on earth was down, fights had broken out, and banks were turning people away.

She fell asleep on the couch with the TV murmuring, and after midnight a gunshot woke her, followed by screaming. Outside, Miriam and Logan burst from their house calling for help.

Their son was ten years younger than Luke, a kid who’d grown up next door with a girlfriend out of town and friends scattered across the country, all of them behind a screen. When the phones died, he had no way to reach any of them.

At the vigil four days later, with the riots spreading and people speaking seriously of nuclear war, Andi barely recognized Miriam and Logan.

Years ago she’d bought the satellite phone just to shut Mitch up, calling him a conspiracy nut for wanting one. Now she typed with shaking hands, stopping twice to wipe her eyes.

Mitch, I don’t know what’s happening anymore. I don’t know where Luke is or if he’s safe. I want to go find him. The boy next door killed himself last night. I can’t breathe. Please call me.

He didn’t answer that day, or the next, or the day of the vigil. She stayed inside with old photographs and the television, where every hour brought new threats and new lies.

The morning after the vigil, she looked outside and found Logan hanging in his front yard. She threw up on her shoes, and since she couldn’t call anyone, she knew Miriam was dead too.

For hours she lay on the bathroom floor clutching Luke’s letters and postcards, too far gone to wash, eat, or count the days.

When Mitch knocked, she threw herself against him, and he held her until she could stand. He disappeared next door for hours, and she never asked what he’d done. When he came back, he told her Miriam was dead.

“We ought to get going,” Mitch said, pulling her back to the present. “I’d like to be out of the city before everybody wakes up. Protests are getting worse, and the looting too.”

“When did you last hear from Luke?”

“Six months, maybe. He was guiding tours somewhere in the mountains.”

“About the same time he called me. He said when the season ended he might head back toward the Slabs.”

“Then that’s where we start.”

“Wait.” Andi pulled the manila folder from the counter. “There’s somewhere I want to stop first.”

She spread the postcards. “Campo. He’s sent me cards from there more than once. I mailed him a letter there once and he got it. I don’t know what’s there, but it’s on the way.”

Mitch studied the postmarks. “Smart, keeping all this.”

“You didn’t?”

“No. I talked to him when he called and figured he’d call again.”

She’d always envied how he could bear Luke’s absence without letting it eat him alive, though she’d nearly forgotten how hard he was to live with.

“Last time I saw him, I was helping him move into an apartment,” Mitch said. “He’d quit some job he hated and spent half the day telling me everything wrong with the world.”

“That sounds like him.”

“Some of his arguments were pretty good, actually. I told him to hang on and give himself time to figure things out.”

“I saw him after that, right before he left.” She gathered the postcards. “I bought him one of those prepaid phones and made him promise he’d use it.”

“He did, didn’t he?”

“For a year or two. Then he called to say it was the last time, that he didn’t want to keep it up but he was safe and would stay in touch.”

Mitch laughed. “Well, that’s Luke.”

Andi laughed with him, though she’d spent most of those two years waiting for the phone to ring.

On the 8, Mitch turned on the radio until something broke through the static, the same fearmongering they’d heard, wars in faraway places over imaginary reasons. The wind farms cut the horizon, and Andi watched the blades turn against the morning sky. They’d brought Luke camping out this way when he was little, and she could still see him scrambling over the rocks, too far ahead, never looking back to see if they followed.

“What’s the address again?” Mitch asked.

“1847 Desert View Road.” She reached for her phone. “I’ll Google it.”

She stared at the dead screen, then put it away.

“Right.”

“Map’s in the glovebox.”

She dug it out from under old receipts, and they worked out which road to take.

The house sat off the highway, a single-story ranch with faded paint, a porch that needed work, and a few things growing in pots beside the chairs. Andi’s stomach tightened as Mitch pulled up, because someone lived here, and she’d imagined an address, a place for Luke to collect his mail, and never someone’s home.

An old man opened the door a few inches. “Can I help you?”

“I’m sorry to bother you. We’re looking for our son, Luke. We think he stayed here.”

“Don’t know any Luke.”

“Please, just a minute.” She was already opening the folder. “I have a picture.”

He took the photograph and held it close to his face, and something in his expression shifted. “Haven’t seen Theory in a while.”

“I’m sorry?”

“Theory. That’s what he calls himself.”

Mitch leaned forward. “You know him?”

“Sure do.” The man opened the door wide. “Come on in.”

He walked slowly with one hand against the wall, and only then did Andi notice how frail he was. “I’m Ronald, by the way. Ronald Franz.”

In the living room, she asked how long he’d known Luke.

“Oh, years now. I met him walking down the road, backpack on, looking like he’d been out there awhile. I don’t usually pick up hitchhikers, but something about that boy.”

“You picked him up?”

“We got talking. He was headed for the canyon to camp and kayak, and he didn’t have much of a plan beyond that.”

“That sounds like Luke,” Mitch said.

Ronald smiled. “He had plenty of plans. He just didn’t care to keep to them.” He settled into an armchair. “I was a Scoutmaster for years, and when he found that out he had about a hundred questions. Camping, finding water, what you could eat out there. We got along pretty good.”

“Did he live here?” Andi asked.

“No, he liked sleeping outside. He had a spot not far off, but he’d come by most days to help me fix things around the house or do yardwork. Good company, that boy.”

“Hang on, I’ve got something.” Ronald reached for a book on the table and opened it carefully, sliding photographs from between the pages.

Luke stood beside Ronald in the desert, thinner than Andi remembered. In another he sat on a rock grinning at whoever held the camera, and she took that one and held it longer.

“He looks happy.”

“He was, most of the time.”

“Where did he go after he left you?”

“Grand Canyon country. He wanted to see how far he could get along the Colorado.”

“I got a postcard from there.”

“He did all right. Picked up odd jobs, met people. I’d hear from him now and again, though months went by.”

“And then?” Mitch asked.

“Then he got himself into some trouble. He went downriver and crossed into Mexico where he wasn’t supposed to, and something happened down there. I never got the whole story, but I believe he was running from someone. He made it back to Yuma somehow and borrowed a phone from another traveler.”

“He called you?”

“Middle of the night, asking if I could come get him. So I did.”

“How old was he?”

“Twenty-five, I suppose. About three years ago.”

Andi looked down at the photograph. Luke had been frightened enough to ask a man to drive all the way to Yuma, and it hadn’t occurred to him to call his mother. She wanted to ask why, and worse, she wanted Ronald to see how much it hurt, but she handed the photograph back instead.

“Thank you for going.”

Ronald looked surprised. “Well, of course I went. Theory needed somebody.”

“Right,” Andi said, and the name caught in her throat like something she had no right to say. “Theory.”

“He is who he is.”

She wanted to keep the picture, but Ronald had so few.

“Thank you for everything,” Mitch said. “You going to be all right out here, with everything going on?”

Ronald shrugged. “I’ve seen enough. I’ll manage as long as I can.”

Mitch shook his hand and held too long.

“One more thing,” Ronald said. “If you’re headed to the Slabs, keep an eye out for Jen and Fred, a couple of transients who spend a lot of time there. They look out for each other.”

“We’ll find them. Thanks again.”

Back in the truck, Andi watched Ronald’s house shrink in the side mirror, and her chest ached. Her son had called a stranger from Yuma, and the stranger had come.

“He’s a good man,” Mitch said, “but in his condition, with no way to reach anybody, I don’t give him long.”

“You think he knows?”

Mitch glanced at her. “I think that’s exactly what he was telling us.”

Andi unfolded the map to give her hands something to do. “When was the last time we used one of these?”

“Before Theory was born, probably,” Mitch said, and laughed, and she laughed with him until it broke in her throat and she turned toward the window.

The Salton Sea came into view, and soon enough the slabs.

At Slab City she watched as they pulled in. Theory had lived among these people and maybe eaten at their tables, and she’d spent two years of phone calls waiting for the next one instead of asking him anything that mattered. She pressed her fingers against her breastbone as if that could hold it all in.

A man outside a trailer recognized the name.

“Theory? Try Elliot. Down there.”

“Friend?” Andi asked.

“Not exactly.”

“What does that mean?”

“They’re intimate, but they don’t claim each other. Neither one’s much for that.”

Elliot opened the trailer door a few inches and no farther.

“We’re looking for Theory,” Andi said. “I’m his mother,” and it came out smaller than she meant it to.

Elliot looked at Mitch, then back at her. “He’s not here.”

“When did you last see him?”

“It’s been a while.”

“Do you know where he went?”

“No.”

Andi took the photograph from her folder, and Elliot glanced at it. “Yeah, that’s him. Why are you looking?”

“We haven’t heard from him since before everything happened. We’re worried.”

“He takes care of himself.”

“That’s what everybody keeps telling me.” Her voice thinned on the last word. She wanted to ask whether he ate, whether he slept, whether he ever said her name, and she swallowed every question.

Elliot’s eyes stayed on the photograph longer than they needed to. “He came around when I wasn’t doing well. He never asked for anything.” It was all she offered, and Andi nodded, because pushing for more felt like something she had no right to.

“Do you know Jen and Fred?” Mitch asked.

“Around here somewhere. Green and white RV.”

Before they left, Andi looked at the trailer, at the patched roof and the single chair and the empty water jugs beside the step. “Can I get you anything? Groceries, some money?”

“I’m fine.”

“Please,” Mitch said. “Deliveries are getting interrupted, and we’ve got extra.”

Elliot looked at the truck a long moment. “Whatever you can spare.”

They filled a bag, and Elliot took it, weighed it, and said, “Thanks.” Then the door closed. Andi stood there with her hand still half raised, a stranger on the other side holding a piece of her son she would never be given.

“I’ve missed so much of his life,” she said as they walked. “I thought leaving him alone was what he wanted.”

“It was,” Mitch said. “Doesn’t make it easy.”

“Everyone seems to love him.”

“Yeah.” Mitch took her hand. “They do.”

They found the green and white RV with Jen and Fred sitting outside, both of them about her and Mitch’s age.

“Theory’s parents?” Jen said. “Well, I’ll be damned. Sit down.”

“He’s practically family,” Fred said. “He worked with us selling books and posters and whatever else we could find, and he earned his keep wherever we stopped.”

“He’s been all over with us,” Jen added. “Oregon, Washington, northern Nevada.”

“Idaho, too,” Fred said.

“Where in Idaho?” Mitch asked. “When?”

Andi heard something shift in his voice.

“Couple years back. Up around McCall, then farther north.”

Mitch nodded and looked down at his hands.

“Have you heard from him recently?” Andi asked.

“He left a few weeks ago,” Fred said. “Went north to help with a harvest at a farm we’ve both worked before. The old fellow who owns it treats his people right.”

“Did he need the money?” Mitch asked.

“Some. But with all this government bullshit, he wanted to make sure the crops got in. Said people were going to need feeding.”

“Did he say when he’d be back?”

“End of the season, he figured.”

Jen stood. “You two eaten?”

“Not since this morning,” Andi admitted.

“Then you’re staying for supper.” Jen was already opening the RV door. “Don’t argue. Theory never did when I fed him.”

Andi tried to answer and found her throat had closed around the name. She nodded instead.

Over the table she asked where the farm was, and Fred glanced at Jen before he answered. “Up north. I’d rather not give out the address.”

“I’m his mother.”

“I understand that.”

“No, I don’t think you do.” Her hands had started to shake, and she pressed them flat against the table. “We haven’t heard from him in six months. Nobody can call anybody, people are talking about war, and you’re telling me you know where my son is and you won’t tell me?”

“Andi,” Mitch said.

“No. You want to know too.”

“Of course I do.” Mitch turned to Fred. “If he’s there, we’ll go get him.”

“Get him?” Fred said. “He’s twenty-eight years old.”

Mitch sat back.

“Listen,” Fred went on. “I know the farmer, and I’ve worked for him myself. Theory’s got a roof, food, and work, and he’s with decent people. If you two go charging up there, you’re liable to make things harder for him.”

“We wouldn’t,” Andi said.

“You don’t know that.”

She hated him a little for saying it, and her eyes burned because she couldn’t tell whether she hated him for lying or for being right.

“I’ll go tomorrow,” Fred said. “Alone. I’ll make sure he’s all right and tell him you’re here, and if he wants to stay on, I’ll leave him be.”

“And if he doesn’t?” Mitch asked.

“Then I’ll bring him back.”

“And if something happens to you?” Andi asked.

Fred took a moment. “Then you’ll have to decide what to do.”

Jen reached across the table. “Stay tonight, won’t you? I’ve got some of his artwork inside, things we sell on the road.”

Mitch shook his head. “I don’t think I’m up for that.”

“Neither am I,” Andi said, though she wanted to see it more than she’d wanted anything all day.

They sat awhile. Andi looked at the RV and the few things Jen had set out for supper and thought about how readily these people had made room for Theory.

“All right,” she said at last. “Go tomorrow. Just make sure he’s alive.”

“I will.”

“And tell him we came.”

Fred nodded.

Mitch rubbed his face. “We can sleep in the truck.”

“Don’t be ridiculous,” Jen said. “We’ve got room.”

It took another round of arguing before he gave in.

Fred unfolded the table into a bed for Mitch while Jen found blankets for Andi on the sofa. Nobody said much about tomorrow. Andi lay awake listening to Mitch’s breathing, Fred begin to snore, and she thought of Theory under some stranger’s roof a day’s drive north, and for the first time in six months she let herself believe he might be lying awake too, not beyond contact.


science fiction

About the Creator

Fatal Serendipity

Fatal Serendipity writes flash, micro, speculative and literary fiction, and poetry. Their work explores memory, impermanence, and the quiet fractures between grief, silence, connection and change. They linger in liminal spaces and moments.

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed. You could also become a paid subscriber, letting them know you appreciate their work.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Fatal Serendipity