Futurism logo

Companies Are Abandoning Peanut Butter Raises as Pay for Performance Takes Over the Workplace in the AI Era

AI is splitting workers into super users and stragglers and bosses are rewarding the difference Equal raises are falling flat

By Behind the TechPublished 7 months ago • 2 min read

The hype around so called peanut butter raises that distribute equal payments to every worker is falling flat as AI divides the workplace into super users and stragglers Companies have given out raises based on performance for years but studies from earlier this year suggested this trend was shifting About 44 percent of employers said they either planned to or were considering giving out equal raises to their employees this year according to one study by compensation software company Payscale Yet a new report by consulting firm Mercer shows this trend has not actually panned out Only about 4 percent of employers in the US are giving out raises in this way according to a recent survey by consulting firm Mercer Part of the reason why may be AI’s influence on a rapidly changing workplace Just under 60 percent of business leaders say technology is key to their business strategy according to a recent report by the advisory tax and assurance firm Baker Tilly and some companies have pushed employees to fall in line Google has begun incorporating AI usage into performance reviews for software engineers though managers have discretion over how it is measured The Wall Street Journal reported earlier this year Meanwhile Accenture CEO Julie Sweet said last month that AI fluency is required for workers to be promoted Still some white collar employees are resisting A global survey of more than 3700 executives and employees by SAP subsidiary WalkMe found that 54 percent of workers were bypassing their company’s AI tools to do their work manually while another third said they hesitated to use AI because it makes their work more complicated And yet another group of workers has responded to management’s push for AI adoption by going all in These AI super users were three times more likely to have received a promotion and a pay raise in the past year Dan Schawbel managing partner at Workplace Intelligence previously said in a statement to Fortune This disparity between employees challenges the idea behind peanut butter raises which aim to address some of the criticisms with merit raises namely that they are subjective and bias prone according to Payscale’s report While across the board raises may seem equal on the surface high performers or AI super users may not see it that way said Hannah Yardley the chief people and culture officer at Achievers a software company that tracks employee recognition and offers rewards If you are just being rewarded the same way as everybody else or being told you are doing the same job with everyone else you are going to feel that it is equal but not fair if you are contributing more to the outcomes of what you have been asked she said Factors like performance but also market competitiveness and internal equity also play an important role in pay decisions added Mercer senior principal Mark Bowling Fairness in compensation often involves more than equal treatment he told Fortune Because not all employee contributions are equal organizations wanting to leverage AI should institute performance based raises but they should also be constantly recognizing employees that go above and beyond so others in the organization know what the company’s priorities are Yardley said Not all work is created equal and so for organizations they should be differentiating in order to be able to set that standard for what value really means in the way that you are delivering she told Fortune Are you an AI super user or avoiding the tools Has your company tied raises to AI skills Share your experience in the comments

artificial intelligencetech

About the Creator

Behind the Tech

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Behind the Tech