Comedian Charlie Berens Mobilizes Wisconsin Against AI Datacenters Citing Tax Breaks and Transparency Gaps
Viral videos and town halls turn local opposition into a statewide movement as 70 percent of voters say costs outweigh benefits

Read Time 6 minutes Tags AI Infrastructure Datacenters Wisconsin Public Opposition Tax Incentives Environmental Impact Community Organizing AI Policy Last summer journalist turned comedian Charlie Berens started getting social media messages from concerned Wisconsin residents about plans for a massive datacenter campus in their state The developer Vantage Data Centers claimed the 8 bn project would largely run on zero emission energy resources like solar wind and battery storage The company said the campus would bring thousands of temporary construction jobs and potentially more than 1000 permanent jobs to Port Washington a city of 13000 people about a half hour north of Milwaukee Residents opposed the project for what they said was lack of transparency and criticized the lucrative tax incentives offered to Vantage They worried about the strain on local water and energy sources from an enormous 13 gigawatt project that could ultimately span 1900 acres Berens who shot to internet fame with his Manitowoc Minute videos that play on midwestern quirks and stereotypes had his own reservations about the artificial intelligence datacenter boom A Milwaukee area native who still lives in the city he d heard about the potential environmental hazards the steep rise in energy costs for neighbors and noise pollution among other risks When he Googled he found that lawmakers in his state had paved the way to make the Port Washington project a reality The deal between Port Washington and Vantage gave an estimated 458m in tax breaks to the developer over 20 years to fund infrastructure for the project with the city not seeing any of that tax revenue during that period It was shocking Berens said That s when he decided to do something he had rarely done before discuss politics in his videos He used his platform to address one of the more polarizing issues in contemporary life what AI portends for Americans In August 2025 Berens published his first Manitowoc Minute video on AI datacenters The two minute skit matched the typical style of Berens s videos where he intersperses facts with humor in the style of a TV news report But he was remarkably direct in his critique of big tech Sporting a Green Bay Packers tie he lambasted Silicon Valley CEOs accusing them of using Wisconsin as a dumping ground for datacenters at the expense of the state s cherished natural resources while evading any type of public scrutiny It is our civic duty to make sure the billionaires become trillionaires said Berens in a satiric bit He channelled his outrage at lawmakers in Port Washington a historic city on the banks of Lake Michigan and once home to thriving fishing and shipping industries In a contentious vote last August officials there approved the initial 8bn datacenter campus despite strong resistance from residents The project later expanded to a 15bn joint venture with OpenAI and Oracle one of the Trump administration s showcase Stargate megaprojects I was shocked at how many people I saw speak against this at public meetings he watched online and then to see a unanimous vote for it Berens said It just felt like an imbalance of democracy The video went viral garnering more than 25m views on YouTube alone Berens s inbox was soon flooded with messages of support from Wisconsinites of all political stripes self declared Maga supporters avowed socialists and everyone in between sounding the alarm on datacenters It was 99 percent positive comments which doesn t happen on anything these days said Berens From that point I decided that I should do more because nobody s negotiating for the people here Berens has since thrown himself into the cause routinely publishing videos and headlining well attended events with field experts and anti datacenter activists He has quickly become the most famous face of a burgeoning movement in Wisconsin where resistance to these projects Port Washington is just one of seven hyperscale datacenter projects across the state has risen dramatically in the last year A March survey from Marquette University Law School found that nearly 70 percent of registered voters in Wisconsin say the costs of large datacenters outweigh the benefits they provide a remarkable shift from last October when that figure stood at 55 percent The attention has placed the comedian in the crosshairs of most of the state s labor unions pro business groups and much of its political establishment who argue the badger state cannot afford to be left behind in the AI arms race On a late winter evening in March hundreds of people packed a community center in Juneau a tiny rural town about 45 miles north east of the state capital Madison The crowd had assembled for a people s town hall to address a 1bn Meta datacenter that has pitted residents of nearby Beaver Dam against their elected officials The featured speakers ranged from community activists to a former Meta employee The main act was Berens who squeezed in the appearance between stops in Iowa and Vermont on his standup comedy tour This is the most bipartisan issue since beer he said in opening remarks In his roughly 15 minute speech he called for more regulation of AI pointing out that a beloved Wisconsin staple bratwurst was more heavily regulated than the trillion dollar industry Berens warned the audience of the risks of AI technology running through a slideshow of news headlines that highlighted the potential and very real harm to children He also addressed his critics I will stick to comedy when our politicians stick to policy and stop protecting big tech and start protecting the people that put them into office said Berens to applause As he turned his attention to the project in Beaver Dam he attacked Meta s use of a shell company and nondisclosure disagreements NDAs that required secrecy from some public officials in the process of getting to an approval In April 2025 a report found Meta was the mystery tech company behind Degas LLC the listed corporation on the development By November the company acknowledged they were behind the project Meta s practices in Beaver Dam are part of a larger pattern across the state where datacenter projects have often been developed in secrecy despite their huge price tags and massive footprint on communities A recent investigation from Wisconsin Watch a non profit news site found that NDAs have been signed in at least five cities in Wisconsin where AI datacenters are proposed or under construction Another panel speaker that night was Maily Kocinski a lifelong Beaver Dam resident whose farm lies less than 2 miles from the 700000 sq ft datacenter campus construction site Last June she posted a TikTok video after a creek that runs on her property had gone dry one morning The water came back but occasionally appeared milky white and gave off a toxic smell Kocinski said she contacted the state s department of natural resources on several occasions and was told the agency collected water samples but were not always able to reach her property in time before the water cleared up again She personally commissioned a water analysis in February from a lab at the University of Wisconsin Stevens Point which found metal levels in her well water above what was considered safe to drink per recommendations from the Wisconsin department of health services She questions whether the daily controlled blasts on the construction site led to disruptions in her water supply Meta commissioned its own study in response denying any link A spokesperson for the Wisconsin department of natural resources confirmed that the department collected a water sample at Kocinski s creek last November The results shared with the Guardian show elevated metal levels but the department did not speculate as to the potential cause Without a site specific review the DNR cannot speculate on the role of the blasting on the aquifer and Ms Kocinski s private water supply the spokesperson said in a statement As Berens s critiques of datacenter projects in Wisconsin have gained traction with the public he has faced pushback from the state s trade unions who welcome the thousands of temporary construction jobs that typically come with a project A major Wisconsin labor leader called out Berens in a December op ed in the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel For us in the building trades data centers aren t some big scary mystery wrote Emily Pritzkow head of the Wisconsin Building Trades Council that represents nearly 50000 workers in the state They re high skill long term work The kind of work that feeds families pays mortgages and sends kids to college Local governments have weighed in too In Port Washington city officials posted a fact sheet online to clarify some lingering misconceptions after Berens posted a second video urging residents to question officials about the datacenter project at an October council meeting Ted Neitzke Port Washington s mayor expressed frustration with the attention that Berens s videos had brought his city He noted that more than 100 people began showing up at council meetings after the comedian published his first video last August forcing the city to move them to a hotel conference center with an added police presence After Charlie Berens s video things escalated very rapidly very contentiously and our city was besieged with people from outside of our town said Neitzke Charlie Berens created chaos for us Neitzke also challenged some claims Berens has made in his videos including those about the amount of jobs the project would create its environmental impact and whether residents power bills would increase I don t know where the line gets drawn between factual and embellishment for him said Neitzke There s a very gray area between the entertainment and the facts Berens defended his videos and the people who showed up to council meetings in response noting that a hyperscale datacenter affects not just one city but the surrounding communities and they deserve a say too He maintained that his videos were well researched and cited news articles to back up his claims I informed people about a massive AI datacenter going up by adding some punchlines said Berens If the truth brings chaos that seems like something the mayor would want to take accountability for On 7 April Port Washington residents passed the nation s first anti datacenter referendum By a roughly 2 to 1 margin voters approved a measure that would require city officials to get approval from voters before approving tax incremental districts of more than 10m The effort came together after a group of residents called Great Lakes Neighbors United gathered more than 1000 signatures in less than two weeks to get it on the ballot The referendum does not stop the 15bn datacenter campus under construction but would apply to all future projects above that 10m threshold Industry advocates have warned the vote could set a dangerous precedent for municipalities across the country potentially paralyzing AI datacenter developments Mayor Neitzke said the referendum makes the city less competitive and puts it at a disadvantage to vie for future projects For Berens the vote reflected the energy he has seen on the ground in Port Washington and in every corner of the state The people who are the heartbeat of this movement are like people in Great Lakes Neighbors United said Berens These are people from all different walks and all different political stripes but they all care about the same thing their community should have a voice Do you think local referenda should be required for large AI infrastructure projects or would that slow critical compute buildout too much Share your view in the comments
About the Creator
Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.
Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.
Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.