Fiction logo

The Last Family Secret

Based on a true story, and dedicated to Laurensa, whose family story inspired this retelling

By Meredith HarmonPublished 6 days ago • 8 min read

Dad was so proud of his three daughters.

Mom tried to domesticate us, and though we learned about decorum and social nicety through her lessons, she raised three hellions. We took no crap from no one, we spoke our mind, and sometimes fought like a clowder of cats. And, like those cats, we pretended nothing happened when it was over.

We behaved during the holidays, though. Three months, three holidays, we didn’t mess around. That’s what Mom wanted, domestic tranquility through the family holidays. The few times we’d had disagreements, we’d take off to the local park, go walking on one of the back paths, and beat the tar out of each other with hairbrushes. Don’t worry, we stayed away from important body parts.

Why? Because Mom was a love – until she wasn’t. And when she got mad, her eyes would turn red, and we’d all pay for it. You did NOT want to be around Mom when she was angry, you would’ve wished you were dead.

Worse yet, no yummy holiday food.

All it took was to miss one Christmas meal, and you’d do practically anything to get back in her good graces. I missed one because I was sick, and couldn’t keep anything down, and the amazing smells wafting up the stairs just about drove me mad. My older sister, she picked a dumb fight over something I can’t even remember, got the banishment, cried for days. Couldn’t have the leftovers, either, and then Dad got in trouble for trying to sneak her some.

Little sister, something about her boyfriend du jour, going to his house for dinner instead or something. She was only thirteen, we weren’t allowed to have boyfriends! Yeah, that ended poorly, Mom made some phone calls, and suddenly little sis was grounded, and on an all-oatmeal diet, while her FIVE boyfriends were made to break up with her publicly. They were glad to do it, when they found out about each other. She cried for days, too, though her skin looked amazing with all the oatmeal.

We put our heads together.

And we decided to specialize.

Older sister, she started watching Mom cook. Took notes on everything – timing, spice pinches were measured, and of what. Went off to college, experimented away from Mom’s complete dominance over the kitchen. Made lots of friends by feeding them her trials, tweaked them, invited us up for a sisters’ weekend a few times, we gave feedback. She nailed the recipes down, wrote it all up, gave us copies. Freaking awesome.

Little sister, she did the same when Mom baked. Usually, when one person bakes well, they can’t cook decent meals, and vice versa, but Mom never got that memo, and excelled at both. Well, little sis got the baking touch. Cookies, pies, cakes, heck, even doughnuts, she can do them all. I would have put on major poundage if she hadn’t gone out and started her own bakery, she’s that amazing. And yes, me and big sis have copies of her recipes, too.

Me?

Ugh. The sauces.

I’m the bridge that only a middle child can be, making salsas, ganache, syrups, icings, tinctures, espresso, fondant, marzipan, bolognese, Hollandaise. Even a mole to die for, a thing Mom never tried.

I got them all down – except for one.

Now, Mom encouraged both of my sisters in their endeavours, eventually, laughed delightedly at their accomplishments. The bakery flourished; college sis took business courses, and opened a small, exclusive, high-end restaurant.

But Mom refused to share with me the secret of her chocolate syrup.

She refused to make it in front of me. She refused to let anyone, and I mean anyone, in the house while she made it. We’d literally get tossed out, and when we were finally allowed back, hours later, there’d be a fresh chocolate cake, or cheesecake with drizzled chocolate syrup, and the Mason jar had been emptied, washed and rinsed till it squeaked, and topped up with the precious fluid.

Heaven knows I tried to duplicate it.

I got recipe books, a library, and the internet. You think I didn’t look? You think I didn’t try? Everything from grinding my own chocolate and blending it, various gourmet chocolate liqueurs, heck, even got some ruby chocolate! White to milk to dark, 98% cacao. Made my own vanilla extract, tried refined and turbinado sugar, and even molasses once. Ground raw sugar off the cone, added a touch of honey.

Every single time, the same reaction from everyone: close, tastes really good, amazing, but it’s not Mom’s.

So I gave up.

I moved away from home. It was easy to get my own place, because my other recipes are as amazing as my sisters’. They called me up all the time for assistance, and I’d make treks to the bakery and restaurant with bottles and jars and boxes, and mix and blend and redact for them. I got a cut commensurate with my skills, and we worked well together. Almost as well as we used to fight.

But I was still angry. Why everything, but that one?

Mom said she’s got to keep one secret to herself.

Yeah, but why take it out on me? Why not keep one secret from each of us, in our own category?

That’s being the middle child for you, and I was pissed about it.

So I went on strike.

I moved farther away, cut contact.

Nothing personal, I said to the others. You have my recipes, you can make them all yourselves, but I won’t be near such blatant favoritism. No, I’m not coming back for the holidays, why would I? I’m a second-class citizen in my own family, and I don’t have to put up with that.

Mom never gave me the real reason. Just me, just the one recipe that was asked for, over and over. The other sisters got everything, and I was given less than equal.

I made my fortune elsewhere. New recipes.

Jams, jellies, all kinds of preserves. My own tinctures, elderflower and teaberry and meadow tea, added to ganache and truffle fillings for divine tastes. I even have my own chocolate sauces, flavored and used. Just not Mom’s. No, I didn’t share any of these new recipes. They’re mine, and I do them well.

The fact that massive orders would come across my desk, to a particular bakery, and a certain restaurant, well, I’d fill them. They’d even get a discount.

Finally, after years, Dad showed up at my door.

He begged me to come home for Christmas. “Look, I shouldn’t tell you,” he whispered, “but your mother’s not doing well. She.. she may not have much more time. We all have your presents stacked up, waiting for you to come back. Please, come home, let her have one last Christmas together. As a family. Meet your brothers-in-law, and your nieces and nephews. Let it be like it used to be. Have a big slice of traditional Christmas chocolate cake-”

Wrong thing to say. I jerked back like I’d been slapped.

“No presents,” I hissed. “You know what I want. One thing. One thing only. Think of it as a favor, to the child that got the hind teat.”

He hung his head. “I can’t promise. I don’t even know, or I’d have told you long ago! She won’t tell anyone, refuses to talk about it.”

“Well, you have a month to convince her. Now, if you’ll excuse me, I have my own Thanksgiving dinner to make, without her recipes. And lots of things with my own chocolate sauces, the chiptole and the lavender honey and the milk adobo and the ruby raspberry. Because I’m done trying to prove to the hard-headed, that I’m worthy of the final secret.” And I slammed the door.

I went anyway.

I brought nothing, and I got nothing.

I did meet my nieces and nephews, and my sisters’ husbands. We talked about anything else but the chocolate-covered elephant in the room, and I learned all about raising kids with businesses to run, with cheerful husbands gleefully accepting the caretaker roles. It worked for them, and that’s all that matters. Decent guys, supportive of their spouse’s career, it was all good.

Then came dessert.

I could feel the tension as Mom’s chocolate cake came out. Their eyes pleaded as mine narrowed. What was going on?

They cut the first slice, and slid it to me.

I took a bite.

And all but spit it out. “This isn’t Mom’s chocolate sauce. This is one of mine, two if I’m not mistaken, it’s my 98% Dark mixed with my Smooth Milk.”

Little sis snorted. “Told you it wouldn’t work. You all owe me fifty bucks each.”

I was done. They were still shouting when I walked out.

I changed my phone number, bought a house with a professional kitchen.

A few years passed before a P.I. knocked on my door to tell my Mom was gone.

Well, what did he want me to do? I wasn’t going to the funeral.

It wasn’t long before the P.I. was back, telling me Dad had joined her, and the sisters were begging me to come back.

Well, I went. Me and my own wife – yes, you heard me – sat together, with the brood we’d started. Our kids, though younger, got along like gangbusters with their cousins, and soon the whole pack of them was terrorizing the graveyard. I think both of them would have approved.

We went back to the house, so empty, with both their presences gone.

“We have to clean it out,” said older sis. “I can’t do it alone, please, help me deal with this, the memories, the stuff.”

I couldn’t help it. I went to the fridge, opened the door, looked for the mason jar.

It wasn’t in the door at its usual spot. I dug around, found it in the back, with dried old crusty remains in the bottom. It looked like it hadn’t been opened-”

“Since you left,” whispered little sis. “She just – stopped. As soon as you went into production, she used yours. Didn’t touch the jar. Told us she was done with it. Never again.”

I sat at the kitchen table heavily.

We started there.

Division of the pots and pans was easy. Our spouses wrangled kids and checked in on us occasionally, and we divvied according to our specialties. I claimed the saucepan, the measuring cups. Little sis got the old pottery pie dishes and the spice jars. I was fingering the nutmeg and cinnamon, and working up a new sauce recipe in my head, when older sis banged her head on the kitchen sink for the third time, and cursed.

“Could you help get in the back corner? I just can’t fit. You’re the thinnest of us, would you mind?”

“Not at all, sorry, I should have thought of it sooner. I was lost in memory.”

They nodded, understanding, when I crawled in.

I passed the stuff out, one by one, and their hands grabbed and stacked on the table. One thing was left, hidden in the back, behind some newspaper and Heaven knows what else. I grabbed the bottle, it felt like – plastic?

I scooted out backwards with it.

Saw what it was.

Fell down, hard.

We laughed. We cried.

The others crowded in, wondering if we were all right, and saw. And joined in the laughter, the tears. Of all the stupid stuff…

The label, though old, was very clear.

HERSHEY’S GENUINE CHOCOLATE FLAVOR SYRUP.

family

About the Creator

Meredith Harmon

Mix equal parts anthropologist, biologist, geologist, and artisan, stir and heat in the heart of Pennsylvania Dutch country, sprinkle with a heaping pile of odd life experiences. Half-baked.

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Meredith Harmon