Fiction logo

The Lake

A short horror story

By K-jayPublished about 19 hours ago • 8 min read
The Lake
Photo by Justin Kauffman on Unsplash

The fall air was crisp and cool, promising the coming of winter but not quite delivering it yet. It danced over the lake, giving an almost mystical blue hue to the already stunning, massive body of water. The lake would have been calm if not for the gentle bobbing of the boat Katherine and her fiancé, Matthew, were currently aboard.

Katherine sat at the rails, looking at the water, enjoying the cool, refreshing splashes that occasionally reached her. She didn't particularly like boats or water, a point she had made to Matthew a dozen times, but his family owned the lake, the land around it, and the beautiful cabin nestled in between. She had to admit she was beginning to feel glad she had allowed herself to be talked into this.

Then again, she would do anything for Matthew.

"Beautiful, isn't it?"

Katherine jumped.

"Dammit, Matthew, don't sneak up on me like that. What, you trying to knock me overboard?"

Matthew laughed. "Of course not, sweetie. Wouldn't want you to drown."

Katherine turned around and embraced her fiancé.

"I know you would save me, Matt."

"You think so?"

"You better."

Katherine couldn't help but glance up at the sky. She didn't know what drew her attention there, but now that she had, she couldn't help noticing the dark clouds forming behind them.

"Matt, I think we should head to the dock. I see some pretty gnarly clouds forming."

Matt said, "Aye aye, captain. What, are you a seaman? Relax, it's just a little rain. We'll be nice and cozy in the cabin."

An hour later, it was anything but cozy.

Rain hammered the deck of the boat, flooding the vessel. Darkness had settled in with the time change, and the lake rocked violently beneath them.

"Honey, I think you were right. We need to leave!" Matt yelled.

"I'm going to draw the sails! You hoist the anchor!" Katherine shouted back.

Matthew moved toward the sails while Katherine made her way to the anchor. The boat rocked violently beneath them, making every movement difficult.

Katherine reached for the anchor chain. Just then, she heard Matthew scream.

"LOOK OUT!"

She turned in time to see the boom of the sail swing violently toward her. It struck her with tremendous force, sending her over the railing and into the dark water below.

She thrashed and kicked, yelling for help to no avail. She felt her body tire, her lungs burn from screaming, and the surge of water push into her mouth and throat.

As she slowly drowned, she swore she could see Matthew standing on the boat, looking down at her.

Smiling.

The next day, the police, the news, Katherine's sister, and Matthew's mother were all there. The police took Matthew in for questioning, but Katherine's death was ruled an accident.

Matthew was free of any charges.

About a month later, he filed the insurance policy. A million and a half dollars.

By early January, he was heading out to stage the cabin and the boat for sale. He brought his new girlfriend, Tiffany, along for emotional support.

"Wow, Matthew, this place is beautiful. Are you sure you want to sell?"

Matthew said, "Absolutely. We're going to take this money I get from selling the cabin and boat and put it with what I have left from the insurance money and travel. Backpack through Europe, sip wine from a vineyard in France, dance in Spain, watch the sun set from a beach in the Caribbean."

Tiffany smiled. "I don't care what we do or where we go, as long as we're together."

Matt couldn't agree more.

"Okay, I promised to come out here and help, but I have to get some work done."

She pulled her laptop out of her suitcase as she spoke.

Matt said, "Okay, okay, I know the deal. Let me grab you some water and snacks, and you can set up in the study."

Tiffany set her laptop on the mahogany desktop, opened it, and logged in. Matthew poured her a glass of water and went to set the pitcher and glass next to her computer.

KNOCK. KNOCK. KNOCK. KNOCK.

"Tiffany, you expecting company?"

Matthew looked toward the front door.

"Absolutely not."

They both went to answer it, but no one was there.

Matthew glanced around the porch and shrugged.

"Must've been the wind."

Tiffany looked toward the trees.

"Some wind."

They returned inside.

A few minutes later, Matthew went into the kitchen to grab something. When he returned, he found Tiffany standing in the doorway of the study.

"What's wrong?"

She pointed toward the desk.

"Oh my God! Matt, what did you do?"

The pitcher had somehow tipped over, spilling water all across the mahogany desktop and directly onto Tiffany's laptop.

Matthew stared at the mess.

"I am so sorry, Tiff."

"It's fine, Matthew, but I've got to drive home and get my spare laptop. I'll only be gone an hour, maybe an hour and a half."

"Okay, I understand."

He helped her gather her things and walked her to the door.

After watching Tiffany pull away, Matthew stood at the window for a moment before turning back toward the house.

He looked at the damaged laptop sitting on the desk.

"Well, that was unfortunate."

He poured himself a drink and settled into the living room. The cabin was quiet, the kind of quiet that comes with being miles away from civilization.

He glanced around the room, taking in the expensive furniture, the beautiful woodwork, and the fireplace.

A million and a half dollars.

Not a bad return for a tragic accident.

He smiled to himself.

Outside, the wind picked up.

Matthew looked toward the window. Dark clouds were rolling in, much darker than he remembered seeing earlier. Before long, the first snowflakes began drifting past the glass.

He checked his phone.

No service.

"Great."

He took another drink and went to check the thermostat. The temperature was dropping quickly. He adjusted it and returned to the living room.

A few minutes later, the lights flickered.

Then everything went black.

"Seriously?"

Matthew tried the breaker. He flipped it a few times, but nothing happened.

He used his phone flashlight to find some candles and got the fireplace going. Once the fire was burning, he settled into his chair, hoping the power would return soon.

The cabin was quiet again.

Too quiet.

He couldn't shake the strange feeling that someone was watching him.

He glanced toward the hallway.

Nothing.

Then he heard something.

A faint dripping sound.

Drip.

Drip.

Drip.

Matthew looked toward the kitchen.

"Must be the plumbing."

He got up and investigated, but found nothing. The floors were dry. The faucets were off.

He shook his head and returned to the living room.

Then came the knocking.

KNOCK. KNOCK. KNOCK. KNOCK.

Matthew looked toward the front door.

"Who is it?"

No reply.

He approached the door and looked through the peephole.

Nothing.

He waited a moment before turning away.

KNOCK!

Matthew swung the door open.

"All right, you son of a—"

Nobody was there.

He stepped onto the porch and looked around. Snow was beginning to accumulate, and the wind was picking up.

"Very funny."

He closed the door.

Then all at once, a powerful gust of wind rushed through the house, knocking out every candle.

The fire in the fireplace seemed to shrink.

Matthew stood motionless.

This wasn't an ordinary draft.

The cold that followed was beyond anything he had ever experienced. It was as if all the heat had been pulled from his body at once, chilling him down to his soul.

Then he heard it.

"Why, Matt?"

He froze.

He knew that voice.

No.

It couldn't be.

"Who's there?"

A faint sound came from somewhere behind him.

It sounded like someone gasping for air.

"Why did you leave me, Matt?"

The front door slammed shut.

Matthew rushed toward it and grabbed the handle.

It was ice.

He couldn't even turn it.

The temperature inside the cabin continued to plummet. His breath became visible, and the warmth of the fireplace seemed to have vanished entirely.

Then he heard the sound again.

Water.

The unmistakable sound of water moving, sloshing, and dripping.

Matthew looked down.

His shoes were wet.

He hadn't stepped outside.

"What the hell?"

Then the voice returned.

"I loved you. You left me. Left me to drown. Left my body to freeze."

Matthew stumbled backward.

He could barely breathe. His fingers were growing numb, and his body began to shake uncontrollably.

The cabin had become a meat freezer.

Then, from somewhere in the darkness, he heard her again.

"Find me. Bury me."

Matthew collapsed to the floor, curling into himself for whatever warmth he could muster.

"Y-you're right. I did leave you to drown. I let you freeze. I'm sorry. How... how can I make it right?"

The voice answered.

"Find me. Bury me."

Matthew would have agreed to anything to make it stop.

"Okay!"

As soon as he said it, the lights cut on.

The door opened.

Outside, the snow was already ankle-high, and it continued falling in thick sheets.

Matthew slowly got up from the floor. He could feel the blood circulating through his fingers again. He stood near the fireplace for a few minutes, trying to regain his strength.

Then he remembered what she had said.

Find me. Bury me.

He wasn't about to spend another minute in that house.

He layered his clothing and jackets, put on a hat and gloves, grabbed a chisel and hammer, and headed out.

"Okay, bitch. I do this, we are done, you hear me?"

Nothing responded.

"I mean it. Leave me alone. If you've been watching, I paid off your mama's house and put that brat of a sister of yours in college for her first semester. We're even, you got that?"

Silence.

Matthew headed toward the lake.

It was thirty minutes from the cabin, ten on the ATV he couldn't get started, so he walked.

By this time, the lake was completely frozen over. To reach the spot where he had murdered his fiancée, he would have to walk another forty-five minutes across the ice.

The wind cut through his clothing as he made his way across the frozen surface. Snow whipped against his face, and his boots crunched against the ice.

By the time he reached the spot, he could barely move his hands, let alone swing a hammer and chisel.

Still, he tried.

He got down on his knees and attempted to position the chisel against the ice.

It slipped from his fingers.

He picked it up and tried again.

His hands wouldn't cooperate.

He raised the hammer.

It dropped.

Matthew stared down at his trembling fingers, realizing he might actually die out there from the cold.

Then he saw something.

A dark shape beneath the ice.

It was moving.

At first, he thought it was a shadow, but it was getting closer.

He leaned forward.

A face appeared beneath the frozen surface.

Pale.

Familiar.

Katherine.

Matthew tried to scramble backward, but his legs wouldn't respond.

Then the ice beneath him cracked.

CRACK.

He looked down.

CRACK.

A long fracture spread beneath his knees.

Then all at once, the ice gave way.

The freezing water flooded his senses. He screamed, but the water swallowed the sound.

Two arms reached out from the darkness and grabbed him.

He kicked and fought, desperately trying to break free, but the grip only tightened.

As he was pulled beneath the surface, he saw her face.

Katherine's eyes were open.

Her expression was calm.

Almost peaceful.

"You're mine, Matt. Forever."

That was the last thing Matthew heard as he was swallowed up by the lake.

THE END

Horror

About the Creator

K-jay

I weave stories from social media,and life, blending critique, fiction, and horror. Inspired by Hamlet, George R.R. Martin, and Stephen King, I craft poetic, layered tales of intrigue and resilience,

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed. You could also become a paid subscriber, letting them know you appreciate their work.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by K-jay