Hidden Family Relationships

If you had believed that you would always be safe there... It turned out that you were wrong.

Dulce believed that they would always live in that beautiful house. After taking on the wreck of the beautiful Cornish Cliffside house that Braylon had obsessively constructed and renovated, he became famous. As a family, they'd spent countless hours on the sofa, watching the storms, anger and frustration over the sea below. It was the house where they'd made a promise to keep each other's secrets secret...

That is, until now. Braylon was with someone he should not have been with because he had fallen head over heels in love. Anyone who isn't Dulce. And their beautiful family house no longer feels like such a safe haven.

On the other hand, Dulce believes that this is her house, and she intends to stay. Even the hidden family secrets contained within it seem to belong to her. Someone, however, disagrees. And, as threats begin to arrive at her front door, it becomes clear that someone is willing to go to any length because someone wants to destroy everything that gives Dulce a sense of security.

A gripping psychological thriller about the secrets hidden in the world's most beautiful houses.

This eBook is available at Amazon or click here to view details.

Chapter 01

It seemed like a wedding. Individuals freezing, blossoms showing up, outsiders in covers stumbling into my grass. Champagne woodwinds wavered like glass towers very nearly breakdown as I seized a signalling horn from conveyance vans pulling up excessively near one another external the house. Meandering around the front, I flinched somewhat at what resembled a seventeen-vehicle stack up, however clearly was simply leaving. I needed to turn away as a little truck attempted to move around a few different vehicles. Our limited, winding path was unreasonably delicate for such movement.

It was pre-fall, the sun was high in a really blue sky, the pungent air shivered with assumption. Life was acceptable, and however I ached to remain in the nursery, I felt remorseful and went inside to check whether I could help. It didn't feel like my home. We'd been attacked by 'party individuals', cooks striving to give this to me, for us. I was energized, and appreciative, and remained in the kitchen, feeling somewhat futile as the specialists took care of their work.

It was my silver wedding. A quarter century of marriage, two kids and an excellent home, roosted – some said problematically – on the edge of a bluff sitting above the Atlantic in Cornwall. My help obviously wasn't required here, so I meandered to the window and looked out at the ocean past the nursery, my musings skipping among apprehension and bliss. Around evening time, Braylon and I would praise our marriage, and the existence we'd made, and we'd drink champagne, our grins wide as loved ones disclosed to us how fortunate we were. In any case, any individual who's always been somewhat fruitful at anything will advise you, karma just has a little impact, and difficult work, arranging and expectation were my elements for a marriage. Indeed, they were my elements for most things throughout everyday life, this evening's party notwithstanding, and I hadn't left anything to risk. I'd pored over each canapé formula, cleaned each sheet of glass, tidied the white screens and styled the nursery nearly to death. Before long I would invite our visitors happily, a word and a beverage, the ideal spouse, leader and mother, my attractive husband close by – when he at last turned up.

Our story started miles away in London, where we met, however, as far as I might be concerned, London was an interruption, and my genuine was continued when we returned here, to Cornwall and my youth home. This six-bedroomed, four-bath roomed white, workmanship deco house had been better when I initially returned, however throughout the long term it turned into the material on which we'd painted our life. An ongoing challenge for the two of us, Braylon had in a real sense made a vocation from our home, changing it from a lovely old relic, to something contemporary, and outwardly shocking. He'd went through the primary long periods of our marriage destroying dividers, while adding augmentations, glass, light and space. Time, love, sweat and tears had gone into this house, and here and there it appeared as though we were woven into the actual texture of the structure. We lived in it, and it lived in us; our foundations were wound through here, folded over the house, and one another.

'Imprint and I are so unique, and we frequently quarrel over what works and what doesn't,' I'd told a red-haired columnist just the earlier day. The meeting was for an insides magazine, and I'd been complimented to be asked; my significant other was the star. Be that as it may, Serenity Cooper – the writer who'd been shipped off talk with me – appeared to be quick to know where I fitted into things, both actually and expertly. She was youthful and pretty, near my girl's age, and lovely to visit to, so I requested that she stay for lunch. Over home-made quiche and salad from the nursery, I'd disclosed to her about our lives, well the PR form obviously. Then, at that point Braylon got back home early, and went along with us for lunch and was before long the middle of everyone's attention, speaking enthusiastically about his next plans for our home, and for the program.

'A real time feature in America is keen on The Forever Home,' he declared, and she sat up in her seat, investigated at me for affirmation, and I grinned ungracefully. I didn't understand he was intending to tell anybody, in particular a writer; it was, at this point, just 'talks' and I'd been committed to mystery.

'Ooh, America?' she moaned, looking at him.

'Indeed, we're truly trusting this falls off,' I added, realizing she would telephone this in to a newspaper in practically no time on the off chance that I didn't retreat somewhat. 'Imprint's continually looking forward with the program, connecting for new stages,' I heard myself say, seeming like a bleeding PR lady. 'He blossoms with novel thoughts, contemporary stuff, continually rethinking, planning new looks, while I love old stuff – vintage, decrepit stylish, and… ' I'd began attempting to get the discussion back onto plan – which was, all things considered, why she was here.

'Emergency room, when you say you love old stuff, I trust you're not alluding to your better half,' Braylon had cut in, winking at me. We as a whole chuckled, and I'd looked as flawless Serenity tasted her espresso gradually, looking over the edge at my significant other.

'It's valid however, dear,' I'd said, grinning at him affectionately, 'you're continually venturing into the future, yet I wait before. I'm glad there. This house has protected the past for me,' I added, going to Serenity. 'At the point when Braylon had wrapped up changing our home, and we had the thought for him to chip away at different homes, this one remained as it was. Indeed, it's excellent with its enormous glass divider looking onto the ocean, the high roofs, and the whitewashed bends of the outside dividers, giving an entire craftsmanship deco vibe, yet to me it's quite a lot more. The scrape marks at the lower part of the steps where the youngsters hustled to get to the base – or top – first, and the estimating diagram on the divider around there.' I'd highlighted the back divider where my pencil had outlined the development of my two kids. Little lead obstacles, practically undetectable, however I realized they were there, a record of the yearly commencement to my children growing up. Leaving the home, and discovering new spots to call home. As far as I might be concerned, the house clutched the past; at times I swear I heard the kids' giggling going through the lobby. Their chuckles pursued me around rooms, and out into the nursery, where more recollections would hurry to meet me in a discombobulated breeze of salt and seagulls. It had consistently been a house brimming with glad commotion, battered, delightful couches, and windows so large and high my child once swore he saw paradise. Furthermore, in a way it had consistently been my paradise. The house was our creation, a third youngster and mine and Braylon's window to the world. Our home represented us – on YouTube, TV, and Instagram. We didn't have to tell anybody how painfully cool/glad/well off/complete we were – in light of the fact that our own special sea shore house in Cornwall said everything for us. Regardless of whether, now and again, it lied.

Our marriage, similar to the house, had endured storms, however we were still attached, dissimilar to so large numbers of our companions, who'd unfortunately been deserted or removed from their own relationships. We were one of only a handful of exceptional couples left standing, and I looked forward especially to denoting this with those we cherished, who might ring glasses and wonder resoundingly at our courage. Let's be honest, any individual who's been hitched in excess of a couple of years realizes it isn't the sentiment, the enthusiasm or even the children that keep two individuals together – it's sheer ridiculous assurance.

'Mrs Smith?' I was abruptly awoken from my musings by Semaj Xzavier, who'd come to assist with the arrangements. Xzavier and Son had consistently had an incredible standing locally, and Semaj's dad was the main manufacturer we'd acquired on our home venture a very long time previously. When the program took off and was on TV, Braylon turned into the moderator/creator and recreated the show's recipe with different homes all through the UK. By then, at that point, we had the youngsters, so I remained at home, actually contributing thoughts, assisting Braylon with his contents, and whatnot. In the meantime, the TV creation group dominated, going to areas with Braylon, remodelling 'permanent spots to lives’ all over the place. Semaj's father Ted came as the off-screen developer on the TV series and worked with the TV group until his demise three years prior. Jaxson, Semaj's sibling, had dominated and kept on working with Braylon, frequently heading out to areas with him, while Semaj went off voyaging, returning as of late to accomplish the work nearby to Looe, here in Cornwall. I recollect Semaj's father saying he didn't care for the TV cameras: 'My oldest isn't keen on being on the television, Dulce,' he'd said in his rich, Cornish intonation, and Semaj talked in something similar, coagulated cream voice with the phantom of Ted's grin. I'd watched him before that evening as he'd painstakingly pre-arranged the ground and taught a little group to raise the marquee for the party, expertly co-ordinating all staff and hardware as self-designated project director. 'Is Mr Smith here yet?' he was asking me now.

I shook my head. Imprint had been expected home around two hours prior, and I was making a decent attempt not to become restless. All things considered, he was regularly late home from the studio. After a long period of living with somebody who worked in TV, I was utilized to it, however today was unique, and I needed everything to be exceptional. 'He shouldn't be much longer,' I said, more to myself than Semaj. 'I revealed to him today we may be praising a quarter century marriage however in case he isn't home by 4 p.m., we will not be commending 26 years!'

Semaj giggled. 'Gracious dear, well I trust he turns up, in light of the fact that the champagne's shown up. You can't drink everything all alone,' he said, grinning.

'You need to wager? I like a test.'

He grinned once more. 'Indeed, you can't begin drinking it yet – the conveyance driver needs to stop up. We could do with moving the vehicle… do you have the keys?'

'Sorry! It's Braylon's vehicle. He most likely has the keys on him,' I said, reviling my better half, who had presumably absently put his keys in his pocket despite the fact that the creation group were driving him to and from area. 'He ought to be back soon,' I offered, genuinely taking a look at my watch; it was currently very nearly 6 p.m.

'We may need to give it a push. Mr Smith will wouldn't fret, will he?'

'No, and it doesn't make any difference on the off chance that he does. Needs should, Semaj, and assuming there's a truck loaded with alcohol, I'm anxious about the possibility that that takes need over his vehicle,' I chuckled.

'Much appreciated, Mrs Smith,' he said, grinning at my joke. Semaj was gorgeous, likely in his mid-thirties, with a tad of a strut. He grinned a great deal. He grinned at me. He was extremely amiable, too amiable truly – with his Mrs Smith this and Mrs Smith that.

'I've advised you, call me Dulce. "Mrs Smith": it causes me to feel old,' I shouted toward him. Feeling old.

He put his thumb noticeable all around and answered, 'Sorry,' without pivoting.

The kitchen was getting going, and I felt in the way, so meandered through to what Olivia, our oldest, and used to call 'the daylight room'. Pointing toward the south, it was soaked in Cornish daylight a large portion of the day, and on summer nights the dividers turned shades of orange as the sun gradually set. The TV organization used to adore shooting in here, and me and the children would twist up on the cream couches watching Braylon do PTCs (TV represent pieces to camera) upholding the new brickwork, the finished nursery, the pitiful stylish side tables, picked by me, trying to stamp my domain. Pitiful stylish was extremely popular in the last part of the nineties, and Braylon would giggle warmly at what he alluded to as 'Dulce's refined insights'. However, that was the place where we varied: I considered the to be as an absolutely real thing to be supported, added to, while Braylon considered it to be something to change, to make over, do up. He would never stop, and whenever he'd painted the dividers in the most recent shade, he needed to move onto the following most recent tone. A long time before the party he'd recommended we change the blurred stripes, white screens and pale-walled insides from Cape Cod Beach House to 'something more tense'.

'What?' I'd said, chuckling.

'Tense, mechanical, uncovered block facades and… '

'No Braylon,' I'd cut in, astonished at the possibility of living in a mechanical stylish distribution center, also the commotion only in front of our party. 'For what reason do you generally do this – we love this beachy look, it's new and clean and suits the setting. We've at long last got it exactly how we need it – however that is so ordinary of you, when everything's ideal, you need to transform it.'

'We can't become complacent now, sweetheart,' he'd said, kissing me on the lips, his method of attempting to allure me into uncovered brickwork, corroded lines and cold substantial ground surface.

I grinned now, as I meandered through the house plumping pads, running my palms along the collapsed tosses in shades of blue. I looked around me, viewing at my home as a mother would look at an adored kid. It was awesome, I was glad, and I'd been on the right track to battle Braylon to keep the new, summery look of pastel cloths and white covered windows.

I ventured out onto the decking, feeling the surge that lone pungent ocean air can bring, and paused for a minute to relax. However, all of a sudden, my telephone rang, making me start. 'Dulce, would you say you are alright? Do you require me to do anything, or would you be able to adapt?'

It was my dearest companion, Nevaeh.

'No, I'm acceptable much appreciated. I advised you, I have the caterers in.'

'What? Is that some code word for your period… or… gracious God, it's not the menopause, right?'

'No, genuine caterers, I giggled. 'I said we were unable to bear the cost of it however Braylon said we could.'

'Gracious better believe it, definitely. Express gratitude toward God. That is to say, at 47 you're youthful for the menopause, yet… '

'Nevaeh, can we not talk about the menopause? You and another hundred visitors will be diving on me very soon, my front nursery's a vehicle leave, and my better half is AWOL. The last thing I need is a hot flush welcomed on by idea.'

'OK, yet as you are consistently quick to remind me, I'm a half year more seasoned, so in case you're menopausal, that is terrifying, on the grounds that it implies that mine is up and coming. God, the night sweats… all my silk nighties will be destroyed!'

She proceeded to talk, and I tuned in, with one ear on a discussion between the servers, who assumed the champagne wouldn't be sufficiently cold. My heart sank, warm champagne, then, at that point I took a few to get back some composure and reminded myself I would not like to seem like one of Braylon's TV companions, who'd make statements like, 'It's just television – not life and passing,' while chain-smoking and not accepting a word they'd recently said. I'd been in this somewhat special world excessively long in case I was truly stressed over the temperature of champagne.

'At any rate, I diverge,' Nevaeh was saying. I grinned; she generally 'strayed'. Imprint said she was excessively loud, however I partook in her. 'As you most likely are aware, I was expecting to be with you at this point for moral help, however it's been a bitch of a day,' she moaned. 'Wicked customers beating on about requiring work vehicle roused boots and blue container caps, I mean truly. Last week, they were clamoring for overcoats in sorbet conceals. Someone make it stop!'

Nevaeh ran an online style site, and invested a large portion of her energy sourcing the maddest things of garments for rich ladies with nothing better to stress over.

'One of them was in tears, in real tears, since I'd sold out of great importance glass nano croc-impact cowhide handbag.'

'I'm not even sure what you just said,' I giggled.

'Balenciaga,' she answered, similar to that clarified everything.

'Trust me Dulce it's something breath-taking, particularly in bubble-gum pink – yet not worth biting the dust for. I went through an hour on the wicked telephone to her, I felt like an advisor! God, they're all so consideration chasing. Where's my "personal" time?' she moaned dramatically, however before I could react, she was off once more. 'What's more, presently Bethzy's simply called, saying, "OMG, Mum, I need to converse with you when you return home. It's critical!" I'd just barely left the workplace, and what's the wagering it's something truly pressing like… "Mum, I have a date, we so need to talk about what nail stain I should wear this evening."'

'No doubt, it's extreme being 24 and delightful with uncovered nails,' I chuckled.

'In any case, I'm so heartbroken, I can't be there yet, yet I guarantee I'll be as quick as possible. I've been anticipating my closest companion's wedding commemoration, and end up knowing she's arranged a few cartons of champagne,' she said, 'and after today I'll require a few boxes all to myself!'

'I simply trust it's cool enough,' I said, repeating the servers.

'Jesus, Dulce, what difference does it make? Having swam through a conveyance of proclamation totes, Grace Kelly headscarves and a pressing talk with my over-restless lone youngster, I'll drink directly from the jug paying little mind to how cool it is. See you ASAP.'

With that, she clicked off, and I got back to the quietness, penetrated simply via seagulls. Nevaeh was exactly what I required at that point, somebody to drink with, make me chuckle and reveal to me it didn't make any difference if the grisly champagne was warm. I truly wished she might have come right on time, as arranged, yet it seemed like her day had been really turbulent, and presently helpless Bethzy was having another dramatization. She was a convoluted young lady, very excellent, in a delicate, blonde way, yet appeared to pick unsatisfactory young men to fall head over heels for, which frequently brought about misfortune and anxiety.

Poor Nevaeh, I thought as I pushed my telephone once again into my pants pocket. I'd met her at the nursery Bethzy and Olivia, my girl, joined in and as the young ladies were currently 24, that implied I'd known her right around twenty years. We'd experienced significantly together, and when she'd lost her better half, thirteen years prior, she inclined toward me a ton, and I was happy to be there for her. In the years since Steve's demise, Nevaeh had managed a few beaus, and however her associations with men hadn't kept going, our companionship stayed strong. She frequently said she wished she'd wedded me. 'I wouldn't fancy you, yet essentially we'd in any case be together,' she'd joke.

We were very unique, Nevaeh and I. She was noisy, unafraid to say her opinion, and generally the focal point of consideration. I, then again, was the quiet, calm one, who was there to step in and assume control over when Nevaeh proved unable. She was either exceptionally up or extremely down, and I'd needed to safeguard her through separations and really focusing on Bethzy when life became a lot for her. Nevaeh was, on occasion, rather flaky, particularly when it came to timekeeping and childcare. At the point when Bethzy was more youthful, she'd frequently take off at brief's notification to source design things for her business from some souk in Marrakesh, or an Ibizan hippy market. I'd generally been glad to care for Bethzy in her nonappearance, and in her way, Nevaeh had been there for me. Like around evening time, at the party, I realized she'd quiet my nerves, make me chuckle, and presumably make me drink excessively. Nevaeh consistently put things in context, prevented me from worrying over things – and this evening, that was exactly what I required,

I was particularly apprehensive on the grounds that companions and neighbours made up just 33% of our party list of attendees. Different visitors were Braylon's, the breath-taking partners and new dearest companions he'd got on his showbiz venture.

His universe of TV distinction was overflowing with individuals on the edges of progress, who thought by just being near somebody like Braylon, a sprinkling of stardust would arrive on them. Imprint would visit for quite a long time, offer guidance, even once in a while welcome common sense outsiders for supper. He adored including individuals; there was consistently another person and fascinating at Sunday lunch. I was utilized to it now, however when we were more youthful, I'd be stunned when he turned up with somebody he'd met on the close by sea shore, or at the bar, and advise them to sit down at our table. I recall it as additional work, an interruption. 'We can't stand to take care of everyone in the world you get talking to,' I'd said.

'In any case, he was a particularly pleasant chap,' he'd say, or, 'However they're a beautiful couple and you'd made a lot of food.' I'd understood then that to stop Braylon was to transform him, and something I cherished about him was his thoughtfulness. I'd likewise adored the manner in which he cherished me in those days. It wasn't customary maybe – nor was it awesome – yet when it came to us, especially in those early days, he was inventive, invigorating, adoring.

It was difficult to trust Braylon and I had been together for such a long time. It was a quarter century since he'd conveyed me over the limit of our home. This house was the place where we'd made our family and, aside from understudy lodgings in London during the nineties, the solitary home I'd at any point known. The house had developed alongside me, and from the second we met, I realized I needed to bring Braylon back here, to Cornwall, to my youth home over the sea shore.

Imprint wanted to tell everybody, 'I was respecting her clothing when we met.' It generally triumphed ultimately, and it was valid, as it were, on the grounds that we met at my alumni craftsmanship presentation, and my last assemblage of work was called 'Pants!' It was a fairly sincere endeavour to show how ladies' clothing outlined 'the proceeding with female battle with body awareness in a post-women's activist, conclusion of-thousand year’s age'. Furthermore, when Braylon meandered through the presentation while heading to meet his better half, our eyes met over my silky briefs. I was only 21, and Braylon, the 'more seasoned man', at right around 26. We visited, he revealed to me my work was new and unique, and he cherished the facetious angle, which, in truth, I hadn't actually implied. Yet, he waxed melodious about 'the profundity and pizazz' of my work, 'ribboned with humor', and appeared to know what he was discussing. I was charmed, and when, inside only a couple of moments he'd offered to purchase every one of my pieces, since he adored them so much, I was totally in his bondage.

He welcomed me for espresso, where, over a mogul shortbread and a thin latte, he dumbfounded me with his beautiful face and compelling appeal. A couple of hours after the fact, I was stripped in his confined level in Crouch End, and that was it. A quarter century on, we had two kids, a lifetime behind us and were, around evening time celebrating with potentially warm champagne.

Meeting Braylon had transformed myself from various perspectives; it had taken me from the way I was following, a vocation in craftsmanship, yet had given me back the home life I needed. I have no time, I was pregnant, and deserted my arrangements to turn into the following Araceli Williams and got back to Cornwall. This time, I took Braylon with me and reported to my bereaved mother that a wedding was on the cards. After the underlying shock, Mum started sewing my dress and making enormous arrangements with the vicar.

'We actually joke about the reality Braylon never really requested that I owed him, in any case, amazingly, it was never an inquiry,' I'd told Serenity, the exquisite magazine questioner, the earlier day.

'You have the most ridiculously astonishing life, Dulce,' she'd murmured, after Braylon had left. Yet, I could judge by the manner in which she said this that what she truly implied was that I had the most over the top stunning spouse.

'I do,' I'd said cheerfully. 'I have two wonderful children, an incredible spouse, and this – ' I'd signalled around me, 'this house, which I'm favoured to go through my days in,' I stopped a second. 'In any case, I'd added, inclining forward, my fingers circling into the handle of my now unfilled espresso mug, 'we never underestimate any of it, Serenity.'

She'd inclined in. Like everybody, she ached to know my formula for progress – the shading range of my life, the private insider facts of my marriage, how I brought up my children and collapsed my towels.

'Imprint and I need to work at our marriage like every other person. It isn't generally awesome. Earlier today we had a tremendous contention,' I'd began.

Her eyes had extended – would I say I was going to uncover something delicious, shameful, were things not really amazing all things considered? She was prepared to look for reality, to recognize the blemishes, the genuine lives underneath the polished, family insides, and most likely felt squandered on DIY reporting. All Serenity required was one VIP scoop to escape from composing unlimited stories on paint shades and extravagant deck.

'A contention? You and Braylon?' she'd mumbled. Her writer tongue licked her lips, sparkly red fingernails presently jerking for her pen, which lay tantalizingly at the most distant finish of the table.

'Indeed, it was a remarkable column. I'm happy we don't have neighbours close by,' I'd said, as yet tinkering with my espresso mug. As yet partaking in the game. Imprint had shown me all I thought about the press. We'd found together after the principal flush of VIP that our lives were interesting to other people. My significant other's ideal time presence had kept the interest, the inquiries, the examining, and we were continually trying it. 'Better believe it, we had this truly furious trade in the nursery, everything being equal,' I'd said, stopping. 'He needs to turn our excellent, tough, ocean cleared nursery into a contemporary space – counterfeit grass and organized plants.' I'd feigned exacerbation. The fire left Serenity's eyes. She was expecting something undeniably more delicious. She didn't go after her pen, her mistake was apparent.

I thought now, as I meandered the nursery, about Serenity and all the others who'd needed to know the mystery of our prosperity. From companions to family to journalists, even visit show has, they all asked Braylon, 'Where did everything go right?' A new cover in a Sunday supplement was a photograph of Braylon and me sitting on the couch, folded over one another, discussing a quarter century of wedded delight. The bother was a more modest photograph of us, featured, 'Succeeding at life'.

I was considering this I nearly crashed into an outsider helping a huge load of china through my nursery. 'Succeeding at life'? Maybe it resembled that, yet I wasn't winning the fight to keep around evening time's commemoration party personal. It was starting to look more like an honors function than the festival of a marriage. We were fortunate, we had everything, except once in a while having everything could remove you from what you truly needed.

I proceeded down the nursery, a last handle at a couple of moments of harmony before the frenzy, and inhaled profoundly, taking the summery aroma floating on the air. Getting away from the crashing ceramics, uproarious voices and tense firing up of conveyance trucks, I tasted the quiet, pungent tang that solitary the ocean could bring. Furthermore, standing high on the edge, I paused to rest as sharp shower from the waves spritzed my face. It resuscitated me in practically no time and helped me to remember what I actually clutched. Maybe the magazine with its preposterous affirmation was correct? Maybe Braylon and I were at last succeeding at life? The kids had developed, and our home was vacant, however it was a lovely home. Regardless of my fights at change, Braylon had as of late introduced a wood and glass-framed expansion, with stunning perspectives and underfloor warming. Maybe we'd remain at home together more, as different couples? Things may quiet down and our lives would bode well again after the wild long periods of work and acclaim and youngster raising?

We'd make some amazing progress together, and this evening we would show the world – our reality – how cheerful we were. We'd giggle concerning that first gathering; Braylon while heading to meet another young lady, and me expecting to change the world with my political clothing. I regularly pondered about the young lady he was racing to meet when he'd chanced upon me that day. How since quite a while ago had she held up before she understood he wasn't turning up, and how unique would everything be on the off chance that he'd gone to meet her all things considered?