Fading Photograph
A Bumpy Journey from the Camera to the Paintbrush

Elra stood at her easel as her mind wandered far beyond the blank canvas. She had six days to create a masterpiece, but couldn’t stop ruminating on everything else in her life.
Her husband and their dog, her painfully average day job, her family’s financial difficulties, her neighbor’s troubles with the law — even a then-homeless friend she hadn’t heard from in years — it all swirled around in her head.
She shook herself back into the moment and tried to concentrate. The afternoon sun glinted through the draped window, carrying with it the sounds of people milling about below.
Be here now, she told herself. She took some calming deep breaths. As always, be here now.
Elra and Aren Nettles lived at 429 W Melrose Street, atop a picturesque “low-rise” in Chicago. Nestled in the heart of the famed Lakeview neighborhood, it was the perfect apartment for a visual artist and a town commissioner.
Fifteen years ago, she would have never imagined she’d end up here. She was just a struggling post-graduate with nothing but her art to keep her going. Her best friends were college kids, couch-surfers, and even a few homeless people.
The most notable of which was a young woman about her age named Jenner. As far as she understood it, that was actually her last name but she took it as her first instead. After all this time it was hard to remember, but the real first name was either Sally or Sara.
Elra would always remember her scraggly chestnut hair and wild eyes. Jenner was the type of character that would constantly astound you. You couldn’t really explain her to someone who didn’t know.
Elra would always try to help her to stay positive, buying her things like incense, crystals, and one time even a genie’s lamp.
As mysteriously as she arrived, one day she was just gone. Elra wondered every day what happened, and where she was now.
Right around the same time, the universe provided Elra with a virtual abundance of art supplies and fresh food. She referred to the event as her personal miracle, which started her on her path to success.
She was with Aren even back then, but they broke up about a year later. He moved to Washington D.C. to work as a congressional staffer.
Even from Pennsylvania, she couldn’t afford to follow him. They lived in a small town 70 miles from Pittsburgh, after all. The cost of living was nowhere near that of any city, much less the nation’s capital.
There were weeks of back and forth, and she ultimately decided she couldn’t hold him back. It was the hardest thing either of them ever did, but they split ways.
Newly single, she threw everything into her art. Within thirty months, she went from landing a couple local gallery showings to others in Pittsburgh, to an exhibition feature there, to (astonishingly) The Philadelphia International Art Expo.
Soon enough, she moved to Philly as well. She started to date as she became established in the art circles around the city. None of her potential relationships lasted long, however.
One day, she got a call from Aren. He let her know he was done with Washington and wanted to reconnect. She was both surprised and exhilarated.
She let him know she wasn’t seeing anyone, and gave him her address.
He took a temporary position in local government, and lived there with her for a few months. Then he found an opening in the City Commissioner’s office in Chicago.
Knowing there’d be even more opportunities in the art scene there, she agreed to the move. Their first apartment was cramped and modest, but soon they moved on up.
It took a few more years before Aren won election to be the new Commissioner. As soon as he did, they searched for a new place in Lakeview. The rest is history.
Now here she stood, several years later, working on the most important piece of her career. She needed to have it done in ten days for consideration for a contemporary auction.
She was stuck last week on what the subject should be, but then found a photograph in a box of old keepsakes that changed everything.
It was of her grandmother, Holly Hersheter, that she had never seen before. It was in paling black and white. Not only was that striking in and of itself, but there was also something haunting about it that pulled her in.
The soulful eyes seemed to be in deep contemplation as the young woman leaned on her elbow over a counter. She wore a light-colored sash draped over a seemingly black silky dress. Her perfectly curled brunette locks hung down under a matching feathered headpiece.
Elra was astounded that this was thrown into a box, perhaps by her mother, before she ever got the chance to gaze at it before. It should have been framed on our mantle growing up, she thought.
Needless to say, this became the elusive portrait subject she was looking for.
She immediately struggled with it, however. Something about the curvature of the body, the buoyancy of the locks, the chilling gaze… it just didn’t seem to translate to a painting.
“I think it’s well on the way,” Aren said as she grumbled about it two nights later.
“No,” she said, staring intently at the canvas and comparing it to the photo clipped up in the corner. “I’m just not capturing it. Not like the real thing. I… arrrg! I can’t get it.”
“Yes you can,” he assured her, running over and squeezing her shoulders. She sighed. “You can.”
She tried everything she could think of over the next few days, readjusting here and starting over there, but nothing was good enough.
Her mental energy was wearing thin. Aren did everything he could to comfort her through, but emotional support wouldn’t cut it.
What began as an enthralling family discovery was now a daunting problem she couldn’t seem to solve.
Now she only had five days left. She spent a lot of time staring at the photo, hoping it would reveal something else to her.
“Come on, grandma,” she said aloud. “Come on… Holly. Please, tell me the secret.”
The eyes just kept staring away, however, in the direction of the bay window beyond.
She stood at the easel from noon to 6:30, until Aren finally nudged her to come to the table for dinner.
She refused and he pushed harder. After two minutes of coaxing, she reluctantly went to eat. In the middle of the meal, as she was bring a spoonful of mashed potatoes to her mouth, it hit her.
“Oh my god!” she exclaimed. “That’s it!” She dropped her spoon onto the plate and got up. She ran to the front door.
“Wait!” Aren yelled, stumbling up to run after. “Where are you going?”
“Come on,” she shouted as she threw on a coat. “We have to find antique clothes!”
By the next afternoon, she found the last thing she was looking for: a black feathered headpiece.
The other things she bought were the dress, the sash, and a hair curler. She was going to recreate the photo, in hopes that she could capture the copycat instead.
Aren had a hard time understanding why this would be any better.
“Well,” she said. “How many self-portraits have I done? Maybe I can get the feeling right if I’m painting myself as her.”
“Ok,” he said. “Well… if that’s what you want, we might as well do this right. Let’s reach out to Travis.”
Travis was a friend of theirs, a professional photographer they met at a gallery opening.
He came over the next day with his prized 1960’s Hollywood press camera. It was certainly the relic of a bygone era, complete with a 60-watt shutter bulb.
Aren gasped when Elra came into the room dressed in the elegant evening dress. With the accessories, as well as hair and makeup done to the 9’s, she looked exactly like the type of alluring starlet the camera was made for.
Travis positioned her at the edge of their counter to lean the same way. Once everything was exactly in place, he engaged the camera with the blinding flash.
Elra’s head fell and her elbow slipped. She caught herself from hitting the counter, but fell to the ground with a thud.
“Elra!” Aren shouted as he and Travis ran over. “Elra, are you ok?” He grabbed her and propped her up. Travis held her other shoulder and tried to fan her. Her eyes opened. “Elra! Are you ok? Say something. Elra?” She groaned.
“El…ra?” she repeated groggily. “No, I….” She looked down at herself. “I thought my name is Holly.”
Aren and Travis glanced at each other in dread.
About the Creator
Gabriel B. Shames
I’m an east coast American, interested in writing poetry and fiction as long as I can remember. I took a test in 4th grade where they told me I wrote creatively at a college level!
Hope you enjoy reading as much I as I do creating ❣️
Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.
Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed. You could also become a paid subscriber, letting them know you appreciate their work.
Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.