Education logo

Choosing Wisely: Automated or Manual Testing?

Automated or Manual Testing

By Kajal DigitalPublished 5 months ago 5 min read

Welcome to the dynamic world of software testing! In this exploration, we will dive into a fundamental difference of automated and manual testing that has intrigued developers, testers, and project managers alike. Other than just picking between these two testing approaches, it's about making wise choices that can have a big impact on the success, cost, and quality of your software projects. Software testing is a pivotal phase in the software development lifecycle, ensuring that the final product meets its intended purpose and performs flawlessly. As we embark on this journey, we will dissect the intricacies of automated and manual testing, understanding their core principles and the unique advantages they offer.

Automated Testing

Automated testing is a methodology that employs specialized software tools to execute pre-defined test cases and compare the actual outcomes with expected results. It relies on scripts or test cases written in programming languages to perform tests. These scripts can simulate user interactions, data inputs, and system behaviours, making them a powerful tool for detecting bugs and regressions.

Advantages of Automated Testing:

1. Speed and Efficiency: Automated tests can run quickly and repeatedly, allowing for rapid feedback and quicker bug detection.

2. Consistency and Repeatability: Tests are executed precisely the same way every time, reducing human errors and ensuring consistent results.

3. Coverage and Scalability: Automated tests can cover a wide range of scenarios, making them suitable for large and complex applications that manual testing might struggle to handle.

Manual Testing

Manual testing involves testers interacting directly with the software, exploring its features, and verifying that it behaves as expected. It is a hands-on process where skilled testers act as end-users, meticulously working through test cases, and exploring the software's functionality. This approach leverages human intelligence to identify subtle issues that automated tests might miss.

Advantages of Manual Testing:

1. Human Intuition and Creativity: Testers can use their creativity to uncover unique issues and vulnerabilities, making manual testing invaluable for exploratory testing.

2. Exploratory Testing: This is where testers go beyond scripted scenarios, actively seeking out potential problems and providing valuable feedback.

3. Usability and User Experience Testing: Manual testing excels in evaluating user interfaces, ensuring that the software is user-friendly and aligns with user expectations.

Factors to Consider When Choosing an Approach

  • Large, complex projects may benefit from automated testing's efficiency, while smaller projects might find manual testing sufficient.
  • Tight deadlines might necessitate quicker automated testing, while manual testing can be more flexible.
  • Automated testing is excellent for regression testing to catch critical bugs early.
  • Manual testing excels in evaluating user experience and usability.
  • Compliance testing often requires manual verification.
  • Consider the expertise of your testing team in both manual and automated testing.
  • Evaluate the availability and cost of testing tools and infrastructure.
  • Assess whether your application lends itself to automation. Some apps may be harder to automate.
  • Calculate the return on investment, considering initial setup costs and long-term benefits.
  • Ensure that your chosen testing approach aligns with your CI/CD pipeline.
  • Frequent deployments may necessitate automated regression testing.

When to Use Both Approaches

  • Start with manual testing to explore the software's features and discover potential issues, especially in the early development stages. Once the software stabilizes, implement automated regression testing to ensure that future changes don't introduce regressions.
  • Manual testing can help in identifying potential bottlenecks and usability issues under varying user loads. Automated load testing tools can then be used to simulate heavy traffic scenarios for more precise performance assessment.
  • Manual testing can help identify critical test scenarios that should be automated. Once automated, these scripts can be maintained and executed continuously.
  • Use manual testing for user acceptance, usability, and exploratory testing, where a human's creativity and intuition are indispensable.
  • Manual testing for critical areas can complement automated testing, especially when automation might be cost-prohibitive.

Benefits of Hybrid Testing:

  • Combining both approaches provides a holistic testing strategy that leverages the strengths of each.
  • It allows for early detection of critical issues, efficient regression testing, and comprehensive usability assessment.

Incorporating both manual and automated testing into your project's strategy can enhance its effectiveness, ensuring that you strike a balance between thoroughness, speed, and cost-effectiveness.

Best Practices for Successful Testing

Implementing Effective Automated Testing:

  • Strategic Test Selection: Prioritize critical test cases for automation, focusing on those prone to regression.
  • Script Maintenance: Regularly update and maintain your automated test scripts to keep pace with software changes.
  • Parallel Testing: Execute automated tests in parallel to save time and resources, especially in a CI/CD pipeline.
  • Test Data Management: Ensure consistent and manageable test data to maintain test stability.
  • Continuous Integration: Integrate automated testing seamlessly into your CI/CD process for early bug detection.

Implementing Effective Manual Testing:

  • Clear Test Plans: Document comprehensive test plans and cases, ensuring thorough coverage of the application's functionality.
  • Exploratory Testing: Encourage testers to use their creativity and intuition to explore the software for unexpected issues.
  • Usability Evaluation: Pay attention to user interfaces and experiences, soliciting feedback from diverse user profiles.
  • Structured Bug Reporting: Use a standardized format for reporting issues, including clear steps to reproduce and their impact.
  • Regression Testing: After each manual test cycle, perform regression testing to ensure new features haven't introduced regressions.

Ensuring Collaboration and Communication:

  • Cross-Team Collaboration: Foster collaboration between development, testing, and business teams to align objectives and priorities.
  • Feedback Loop: Create a feedback loop where findings from both automated and manual testing inform each other, enhancing the overall testing strategy.
  • Training and Skill Development: Invest in continuous training for testers to keep their skills up-to-date in both automated and manual testing.
  • Test Reporting and Documentation: Maintain clear and detailed documentation for test cases, results, and any issues discovered.
  • Regular Reviews: Conduct regular reviews of your testing processes to identify areas for improvement and adapt as necessary.


In the ever-evolving landscape of software development, the choice between automated and manual testing is a decision that should be made thoughtfully. As you embark on your software testing journey, consider staying updated with industry trends and tools, as they continually evolve. If you're looking to enhance your skills, you might want to explore a Software Testing Training Course in Ludhiana, Patna, Noida, Kochi or any other location of your choice. So, whether you're a seasoned professional or just starting, embrace the dynamic world of software testing, where adaptability and expertise go hand in hand, ensuring software that meets the highest standards of quality and reliability.


About the Creator

Kajal Digital

I am a Digital Marketer and Content Marketing Specialist, I enjoy technical and non-technical writing. I enjoy writing about training courses in Bhopal Like Data Science, Data analytics, software testing, Java, etc.

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights


There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2024 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.