Critique logo

Thanksgiving

Is the Hype Justified or Overrated?

By Aubrey KatePublished 5 months ago 2 min read
Like
Thanksgiving
Photo by Claudio Schwarz on Unsplash

As the fall season approaches, so does the anticipation of Thanksgiving—a time for family gatherings, feasting, and expressing gratitude. It's a holiday that carries traditions of turkey, cranberry sauce, pumpkin pie, and heartfelt moments shared around the dinner table. Yet, as we prepare for this annual celebration, some voices quietly ponder whether Thanksgiving might be a tad overrated.

Now, don't get me wrong. Thanksgiving is steeped in tradition and carries a rich historical significance. It commemorates a story of unity, sharing, and gratitude between the Pilgrims and Native Americans. However, in modern times, the holiday has evolved into a frenzy of expectations and rituals that might leave some feeling that the hype surpasses the reality.

Let's start with the feast itself. Thanksgiving often conjures images of lavish spreads and culinary delights. While the idea of a bountiful meal shared with loved ones is heartwarming, the pressure to create a picture-perfect Thanksgiving dinner can sometimes overshadow the true essence of the holiday. The stress of meal preparation, coupled with societal expectations of a flawless table setting and Instagram-worthy dishes, can detract from the genuine spirit of gratitude and togetherness.

Moreover, Thanksgiving often kicks off the holiday season, leading to a relentless cycle of consumerism. The day after, Black Friday bargains lure shoppers into a frenzy of deals and discounts, overshadowing the reflective nature of the holiday with a wave of materialistic pursuits. The emphasis on shopping and consumer culture can dilute the essence of gratitude and appreciation that Thanksgiving ideally embodies.

Additionally, the romanticized portrayal of harmonious family gatherings during Thanksgiving can be misleading. For many, the reality of familial dynamics can be complex, leading to stress and discomfort rather than warmth and joy. Expectations of picture-perfect family moments can sometimes collide with the complexities and nuances of real-life relationships, causing a sense of disillusionment.

Furthermore, the commercialization of the holiday season tends to overshadow the significance of expressing gratitude year-round. While Thanksgiving prompts us to reflect on our blessings and express thanks, some argue that this practice should extend beyond a single day in November. Cultivating a daily habit of gratitude and appreciation might hold more value than confining it to a once-a-year celebration.

Another aspect that questions Thanksgiving's hype is the historical context often omitted from the festive narrative. The traditional story of the Pilgrims and Native Americans sharing a peaceful feast masks the complexities of colonization, oppression, and cultural erasure faced by Indigenous communities. Acknowledging and learning about this historical background prompts a reevaluation of the holiday's portrayal, challenging its idealized perception.

Yet, despite these reservations, Thanksgiving does hold merit. It serves as a reminder to pause, reflect, and express gratitude for life's blessings—family, friends, health, and more. The notion of coming together, sharing a meal, and acknowledging our blessings remains a powerful and cherished tradition.

Ultimately, whether Thanksgiving is overrated or not depends on one's perspective and experiences. For some, the holiday might live up to its expectations, fostering cherished memories and moments of heartfelt gratitude. For others, the pressure to conform to societal standards and the glossed-over complexities might overshadow its significance.

Perhaps, instead of dismissing Thanksgiving entirely, there's an opportunity to reassess its essence, focusing on genuine moments of gratitude, reflection, and togetherness beyond the surface-level hype. Embracing the spirit of thankfulness throughout the year might render the Thanksgiving holiday less about the hype and more about the heartfelt sentiments it aims to celebrate.

Theme
Like

About the Creator

Aubrey Kate

I do stuff but we're just getting to know each other so why don't you slow down a bit?

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2024 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.