The Sins of the Grandmother
A Review of Books & Bewitchment by Isla Jewell

Rhea is tired of living in a small town in Alabama where her ex and his brother like to torment her. Suddenly, an opportunity falls in her lap. Her grandmother just died, leaving her everything she had in Arcadia Falls, the place where her mother made her and her sisters promise never to go. Desperate for a change, Rhea decides to ignore her long-deceased mother’s warning and move to Arcadia Falls, where mystery and intrigue await her.
One of the strongest aspects of this book is that knowledge is power. This is especially important to Rhea because she constantly deep dives into books to find the answers to her problems. However, Rhea finds it hard to make an informed decision while in Arcadia Falls. The information she needs is not in a book, but with people long gone. Rhea’s mother never told her why she fled Arcadia Falls or why she was estranged from Rhea’s grandmother. Rhea goes to Arcadia Falls thinking that her mother and grandmother’s squabbles were ordinary.
Unfortunately, when she gets to the new town, Rhea discovers that her mother and grandmother’s problems are much larger than she realizes, and a source of contention for the town. That lack of knowledge makes it hard for Rhea to prepare for pushback from the townsfolk in Arcadia Falls, and she is not quite sure how to fix the mess that both her mother and grandmother left behind. You end up feeling for Rhea because she has all this family drama dropped into her lap that she never asked for and wasn’t even a part of. The situation brings up an important question: Should Rhea be responsible for her grandmother and mother’s actions that hurt the town?
As human beings, we tend to blame a whole family for one person’s supposed transgression. There are kin punishment practices in various countries, like North Korea, that require the entire family to suffer for several generations due to one member’s disobedience. During the Salem Witch Trials, people who were accused of being witches and their families were ostracized and even killed despite the lack of evidence.
In the book, Rhea is shunned by a lot of the townsfolk because of the heinous crime her grandmother committed. One would think her grandmother’s act would haunt Rhea the rest of her time in town, but she brings up a point to someone willing to hear her out: Rhea didn’t know anything about her grandmother. Why should Rhea be held accountable for something she wasn’t a part of? It was fascinating watching the townspeople debate whether Rhea should face the same judgment as her grandmother or if she should be judged on her own merit. The dynamic between Rhea and the townspeople makes for interesting drama as she tries to win them over.
Overall, I really liked the book. I initially went in for the romance aspect. I found Rhea and Hunter's slow-burn romance very heartwarming and mature. I especially liked that Hunter didn’t completely close himself off from Rhea and treated her as her own person.
As much as I loved their romance blooming, I felt it was less important in comparison to Rhea’s journey to Arcadia Falls. She took a big leap to escape a toxic environment and go to a place where she can learn about herself and history. Starting over takes courage, especially since she is facing down the sins of the grandmother she never knew in a town of people who hate her family. If you are looking for something to read that combines the love of books and witchcraft, this is definitely one to check out during October. It is a cozy autumn read that you can binge during the weekend.
About the Creator
Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.
Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed. You could also become a paid subscriber, letting them know you appreciate their work.
Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.