'The Rag and Bone Shop' By Robert Cormier Is Brilliant But Dated
The Kids May Not Be Alright

A killer is on the loose. He murdered a 7-year-old girl, and who knows if he’ll strike again. The town is up in arms. The senator wants answers. All eyes are on the person who last saw the girl alive: Jason Dorrant. Robert Cormier paints a twisted picture of law, order, and justice in The Rag and Bone Shop.
Summary
Jason Dorrant is excited for summer. He is 12 years old, 13 years old in November, and ready for the school year to end. Although not necessarily considered a nerd, Jason is certainly not a jock. He’s had his fair share of bullying at school, but has learned the secret to finding his way in the hallways of Middle School: you have to put bullies in their place.
Alicia is Jason’s 7-year-old friend and also the younger sister of his semi-friend Brad. Jigsaw puzzles are what unite Jason and Alicia and why he visits her house often. It is on that fateful day of Alicia’s murder that she and Jason are putting together a jigsaw puzzle for what would be the last time.
Alicia is killed between the hours of four and five o’clock in the evening. Jason, who left Alicia’s house at around four o’clock in the evening, arrives at his home, which is empty, at around five o’clock. With no alibi and a detective known to get confessions out of perpetrators, the youngster is unknowingly in the fight of his life.
A Slow Start
Some deem Robert Cormier one of the most influential Young Adult writers of his time. Given the date of publication (The Rag and Bone Shop was published in 2001), such a claim may have been true for the time. Cormier certainly has competition in present times, though, with several new Young Adult authors giving him a run for his money when it comes to pace.
The Rag and Bone Shop has a slow start that may discourage young readers from continuing with the story. In particular, Middle School students may find themselves uninterested in the story after page 30 because of all the details that seem unnecessary in the beginning. It is not until the reader gets to about page 50 that the start of the book makes sense. Young readers in this day and age may not be willing to stick around that long.
The Unrealistic Setting
Jason is taken from his home and brought in for questioning without any evidence pointing to him as the murderer. The boy’s mother is not properly informed that her son is suspected as Alicia’s killer. Jason, a minor, is interrogated without his parents present, and he ultimately confesses to a crime he did not commit after being tricked into believing that such admission is in his best interest.
While it is true that confessions have been obtained by way of coercion, the scene Cormier creates in his book is not realistic for the time. It is not unreasonable to believe that law enforcement would at least invite Jason’s mother to come down to the station with him during the early 2000s. Such change in the storyline does not support the scenario Cormier creates, however, as the outside detective leans heavily into isolation.
The Twist At The End
One interesting aspect of The Rag and Bone Shop by Robert Cormier comes near the end as Jason, who didn’t murder Alicia, contemplates the idea of carrying out the thing he was accused of doing. He focuses his attention on the school bully and goes back and forth with the notion of murder. Whether or not Jason carries out the act is left to the reader’s imagination. This twist at the end is brilliant.
Who Is This For?
The Rag and Bone Shop by Robert Cormier is for Middle School readers who are looking for something quick. The book is just over 150 pages in length and is written in a way that adolescents can relate.
About the Creator
Sarie
Hi! My name is Sarie! I write about books and society.
Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.
Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed. You could also become a paid subscriber, letting them know you appreciate their work.
Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.