BookClub logo

It Ends With Us Review: Why This Book Broke The Internet And My Heart

Colleen Hoover's most controversial bestseller is more than a romance - here's my honest review

By V.S Ferreira Published about a month ago 3 min read
Image: Sony Pictures / Review - Blake Lively as Lily Bloom

What is It Ends With Us about? [No major spoilers]

Lily Bloom is 23, just moved to Boston and opened her own flower shop. She meets Ryle Kincaid - a handsome, ambitious neurosurgeon who is absolutely not looking for a relationship. Their chemistry is instant. Intense. Addictive. Just when Lily thinks she has finally found the love she deserves, her first love Atlas Corrigan reappears.

Why everyone is obsessed with this book:

Colleen Hoover doesn't write perfect characters. She writes real, flawed, broken people. Lily makes mistakes. Ryle is not a villain from a movie, he's charming, funny, successful - and that's what makes it terrifying. You understand why she stays.

TikTok blew up because every woman saw a piece of her own story there. It's not a love triangle, it's about the choice between a fantasy of what love should be and the hard reality of what love actually costs.

Content Warning - Read this before you start:

This book contains domestic violence, emotional abuse and scenes that can be triggering. It's not a light romance. If you have been through an abusive relationship, read with care. Hoover writes it with a lot of responsibility, because it's based on her own mother's story.

What I LOVED:

The writing. You read 300 pages in one night. It's impossible to stop.

Lily's flower shop. Every chapter starts with a funny letter to Ellen DeGeneres that Lily wrote as a teenager. It balances the heavy parts.

Atlas Corrigan. He is the definition of "if he wanted to, he would". The only green flag in a book full of red flags.

The ending. It doesn't end how you think a romance should end. It ends how it HAS to end. That's why the title "It Ends With Us".

What didn't work so much for me:

Ryle's redemption arc is too fast. Some dialogues are a bit cringe, very 2016 Wattpad style. And the movie adaptation with Blake Lively softened a lot of the hard scenes that made the book so powerful.

Final Verdict: Should you read It Ends With Us?

Yes, but not as a love story. Read it as a story about courage. It's uncomfortable, it's sad, it's angry - and it's necessary.

If you loved Colleen Hoover, you will cry. If you never read her, start with this one and you will understand why she is the queen of BookTok.

My Rating: 4.5 / 5 stars - It broke my heart in the best way.

Have you read it? Did you team Ryle or team Atlas at the beginning? Tell me in the comments.

Is It Ends With Us better as a book or movie?

I watched the movie the same week I finished the book, and honestly, they are two different experiences. The book is raw, uncomfortable, and you live inside Lily's head. You feel every justification she makes for Ryle. The movie, directed by Justin Baldoni, had to soften a lot. Blake Lively is amazing as Lily - she brings that floral, fragile but strong energy - but Hollywood can't show the violence the way Colleen wrote it.

What the movie does better is the flowers. Lily's flower shop in the book is magical, and seeing it on screen with all those peonies and the turquoise typewriter makes the dream feel real. And the chemistry between Blake and Justin is intense, you really understand why Lily would be torn.

But if you want the real punch, the real reason this book broke TikTok, read the book first. The Author's Note at the end, where Colleen says this is her mother's story, will destroy you. The movie doesn't have that. The book stays with you for weeks.

My tip: read the book in 2 days, cry, then watch the movie with ice cream. You will need it.

RecommendationReviewVocal Book Clubbook reviewreviewproduct review

About the Creator

V.S Ferreira

Storyteller & Reader. I read trending books so you don't have to. No spoilers. No hype. Just honest reviews.

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by V.S Ferreira