Horror Bingo & Supernatural Reads
My October Book Wrap-Up

For October, I decided to do Horror Bingo and read different subgenres of horror all month long. I learned one thing about myself during this time. I can’t read horror back-to-back. While I love horror as a genre, it gives me nightmares if I read that particular genre only. That’s why I mixed in some lighter books to read this October. Overall, I am excited that I was able to fill out my horror bingo card with some good books:
Cults: We Are For The Dark by Gretchen McNeil
Occult Horror: Foresyth Conservatory by A.L. Sterling
Horror novel from 2026: The Southern Sorority of Superstitious Witches by Katie Ortiz
Supernatural: Strange Happenings by Avi
Body Horror: Look What the Cat Dragged In by Jason Rehulax
Psychological Horror: Dive Bar at the End of the Road by Kelley Armstrong
Gothic Horror: The Unknown by Riley Sager
Horror Book Under 250 pages: Wylding Hall by Elizabeth Hand
Bingo Sheet Favorites
Wylding Hall by Elizabeth Hand: Rating: 5.0 Stars
Summary: A British acid folk band is being interviewed for a documentary about the mysterious disappearance of the lead singer, Julian, during the recording of the band’s second album.
Thoughts: I love a good mystery, especially when it is a debate between skeptics and believers over a supernatural event. It’s fascinating because it always boils down to this: skeptics want to believe that there is always a logical explanation, whereas believers want to explore things that are beyond human comprehension. So I am curious about you guys. Are you a skeptic or a believer when it comes to otherworldly phenomena?
Foresyth Conservatory by A.L. Sterling: Rating: 4.5 Stars
Summary: A bookshop owner and book nerd is asked by the Meister of Foresyth Conservatory to use her tarot reading skills to investigate a murder that happened at the conservatory.
Thoughts: Technically, this book falls under cult as well. It seems that often occult groups and cults go hand in hand. I think it is because they have a tendency to explore taboo subjects in society. I think others like me question why people fall for the occult and cults. After reading, I think that I have an idea. People want a sense of belonging and to feel like they are contributing to something outside themselves. Occult groups and cults know how to manipulate those feelings in individuals who are lost and searching for their life’s purpose. It is kind of creepy when you think about it because the people in cults have to be experts in communication and charisma to achieve this, which is exactly why the smart and capable protagonist gets sucked in without even realizing it.
Look What the Cat Dragged In by Jason Rehulax: Rating: 4.0 Stars
Summary: A girl agrees to pet-sit a cat, which leads to supernatural results.
Thoughts: One of the best things that I found with this book is that it includes illustrations from the main character. You can tell through her drawings when the supernatural took over her and her downward spiral. The drawings are a creative touch that I wish more books did.
Bingo Sheet Disappointment
Strange Happenings by Avi: Rating: 3.5 Stars
Summary: Five short tales exploring the supernatural.
Thoughts: There was only one tale that scared the crap out of me, “Bored Tom.” A bored child switches places with his cat because he believes the cat has a better life than he does. Now, have I ever had that same thought? Yes. Before reading this, I would have loved being reborn as a cat and having the option to sleep all day and be lazy. However, after reading… let’s just say the tale gives a great reason why you wouldn’t want that, especially with how dark the tale got towards the end. Considering how horrifying I found that tale, I am curious about what the intended age group for this tale (middle schoolers) would think of this.
Reviews from Bingo Sheet to Come
Dive Bar at the End of the Road by Kelley Armstrong
We Are For The Dark by Gretchen McNeil
The Southern Sorority of Superstitious Witches by Katie Ortiz
The Unknown by Riley Sager
The first three, I can’t wait to do reviews for because they tell powerful messages that I feel need to be told and hopefully spread. I am still mulling over my thoughts about The Unknown. There are great twists and turns. I think I am most conflicted about the ending, though (hint: A Livid Lady’s Guide to Getting Even). I hope to have these out before the end of the month.
The Books That Kept Me Sane Last Month
My Roommate Is a Vampire by Jenna Levine: Rating: 4.5 Stars
Summary: A woman accidentally discovers her new roommate is a vampire.
Thoughts: I found it to be a nice romantic comedy. I liked that the main couple learn from each other and give each other space instead of being totally obsessed with one another (like a certain Twilight character).
The Faraway Inn by Sarah Beth Durst: Rating: 5.0 Stars
Summary: To escape heartbreak, a teenager travels to her great-aunt’s inn for the summer. The inn has seen better days, but the girl sees a magical charm that draws her into the inn and its guests.
Thoughts: I found this cozy fantasy to be a profound read. Running away from your problems is not necessarily a bad thing. Sometimes, you have to remove yourself from a situation in order to evaluate and learn how to approach what comes next. Sometimes, we can do that on our own, but it is never bad to accept help along the way to solve it while protecting our boundaries. I definitely recommend this to anyone who likes learning life lessons, but in a fantastical atmosphere.
Backlog Reviews From Books Read Earlier This Year
The Dungeon Anarchist’s Cookbook by Matt Dinniman: Rating: 5.0 Stars
Summary: Carl and Princess Donut continue their exploration of the dungeon on the next floor, where the Iron Tangle awaits them.
Thoughts: Somehow, I missed reviewing this one, which worked out since I fell sick and was out for a couple of weeks. It is always a riot to see Carl and Princess Donut clearing a dungeon, and this book didn’t disappoint. I would follow Princess Donut and her court anywhere.
The Awake: The Dispensables by Warren Wright: Rating: 4.0 Stars
Summary: A woman is stuck in a VR world with no idea how to proceed forward.
Thoughts: This is an ARC that I read a while ago, but wasn’t able to post a review until it was released last month. I think it is a good read because it sheds light on how people in society try to portray a perfect front even though they are involved in underhanded things that can be downright deplorable. It makes you wonder why we don’t question more when these things happen. Like, did everyone just turn a blind eye to the problem, or were the wicked people really that convincing in their innocent act? It is definitely something to ponder over.
Etna by Paul Yoon: Rating: 4.5 Stars
Summary: A military working dog tries to make the treacherous journey home through a war-torn country.
Thoughts: For a short book, it asks a very profound question: Is war really necessary? It doesn’t have an easy answer. War leads to death, destruction, and chaos on both sides that can take years to recover from. However, if the Civil War hadn’t happened, I wouldn’t have a platform, let alone be considered a human being. Do I wish we had better ways to resolve problems? Definitely! I am just not sure how we as a society can get there.
I Hope This Email Finds You In Hell by Mackenzie Reed: Rating: 4.0 Stars
Summary: A receptionist accidentally walks in on her boss performing an exorcism on her co-worker.
Thoughts: I thought that this was going to be a workplace comedy based on the title alone. Disappointed that I didn’t get that, but I did get something interesting in return. An important lesson: “Misery loves company.” Some people love to find people who are sad and alone and feed off them. In this book, it is in the literal sense. However, some people are emotional vampires who drain everything out of you until there is only a semblance of yourself left. It is important to know how to protect your boundaries so that these miserable people don’t set their sights on you next.
(Mostly) Human Resources by Grace Viall: Rating: 4.5 Stars
Summary: A human resource manager is forced into the field to find one of her wayward Wardens who decided to disobey orders to find an unknown supernatural creature.
Thoughts: This is what I was hoping “I Hope This Email Finds You In Hell” would be like: working in a supernatural place, and how things go wrong. It didn’t have the comedy I wanted, but it at least had the workplace dynamic that I craved, which “I Hope This Email Finds You In Hell” sorely lacks. Also, the book dispelled my belief in jackalopes being cute. Those things are scary little demons, and I hope they are not real. There is a sequel in the works for this book, and I can’t wait for it to come out.
DNF
Eminence Front by Rebecca Rowland: There wasn’t any character to root for, so I stopped reading.
If Books Could Kill by Kate Eberle: I think I would have liked this one more in a different medium. I truly believe this would have done better as a limited TV series or a movie versus a book. The characters don’t really translate well on paper, but if you could get an actor to elevate what’s there, then it would be a definite hit.
TBR For November

This is where you guys come in. The only book I know for sure I am reading this month is Murmuration by TJ Klune. I was so stoked to get an ARC of this book. But outside of that, I don’t have anything else planned. I thought about just picking books that I have already purchased that have been staring at me in dismay in TBR Hell. The picture above shows the books I own. Let me know in the comments what you think I should read next!
That is all that I have in regard to my bookish activities. Did any of you guys do the horror bingo challenge? Let me know in the comments. Would definitely love to hear about more horror books to read. Until next time, happy reading!
About the Creator
Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.
Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed. You could also become a paid subscriber, letting them know you appreciate their work.
Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.