BookClub logo

Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone Review: A Grown Man's Honest Reread

I thought it was just a kids book. I was wrong

By V.S Ferreira Published 3 months ago • 4 min read
My reading copy of Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone on the 11:20 PM train - page 112, coffee stain on the sleeve, train ticket still inside. I opened it to kill time and read 80 pages straight.

I finished Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone on the train at 11:20 PM. I was holding cold coffee, train was 40 min late, phone at 5%, body beat from work. I just opened the book to kill time. Thought I'd read two pages. I read eighty straight. I was on that seat. Thinking about when I was a kid waiting for something big to happen on my street.

What this book really is, no BS

Look, I'll be straight with you as a grown American dude who thought Harry Potter was just for kids and for British nerds. It's not. Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone is not about wands and fancy Latin spells. It's about an 11-year-old kid who sleeps in the closet under the stairs, glasses taped together, treated like trash by his aunt and uncle, who suddenly finds out there's a place in this world where he matters. Where people actually say his name with respect. Where he has real friends.

A lot of guys ask me, isn't this too childish for a grown man to read? I get it. The start with the Dursleys feels like a cartoon. Dudley is spoiled rotten, Aunt Petunia measures sugar like it's gold. Seems silly. But that's on purpose. Rowling makes you feel that tight, suffocating house on Privet Drive so when Hagrid busts down the door in that shack in the middle of nowhere and says "yer a wizard," you breathe out with Harry.

Like my Reviews 🩵🔔

Subscribe

“It does not do to dwell on dreams and forget to live”

Dumbledore - and this line hits harder at 30 than at 12

And when he walks into Hogwarts for the first time, candles floating, staircases moving, ceiling showing the actual sky outside, you get it. It's home. It's that feeling every dude knows, wanting to belong somewhere. The Philosopher's Stone itself is almost an excuse. What sticks is the trio. Harry, brave but insecure, doesn't know what to do with fame. Ron, loyal as hell but scared to death of being the second-best, the middle kid of seven. And Hermione. Potions class smelling like rotten eggs, Quidditch that's basically football in the air, the troll in the girls' bathroom where their friendship actually starts for real. If you only saw the movies, you missed a ton. You missed Peeves, the poltergeist throwing chalk at kids, you missed more of the Mirror of Erised, which in the book hurts way more because Harry sees his parents smiling at him and just sits there for hours.

Unpopular opinion: Hermione is the real main character and Snape is annoying as hell in this book[

You can roast me in the comments, I don't care. In this book Hermione is better than Harry. She's the real main character. Without her, both boys die on page 150. She solves the potions riddle at the end, which is pure logic, not magic. She remembers the Devil's Snare spell when they're choking, she studies all night while those two play wizard chess. Harry is brave, no doubt, but he runs in headfirst, no plan. Hermione thinks.

And Snape? In this first book he's just annoying on purpose. He's mean just to be mean. Yells, takes points from Gryffindor, makes that disgusted face. No layers like he gets later. He's a fake villain so you suspect him and then get shocked by Quirrell. And yeah, the middle drags a little. Between the first Quidditch match and Hagrid's dragon, there's like 50 pages of just class routine and hallway gossip. I love Hogwarts, but as a guy who likes pace, I felt it. Did I think about skipping? Yeah, I did. But I stuck with it.

My reading copy of Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone on the 11:20 PM train - page 112, coffee stain on the sleeve, train ticket still inside. I opened it to kill time and read 80 pages straight.

My reading copy of Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone - train ticket still inside page 112 with coffee stain

After that slow middle, the book kicks in and doesn't stop. The giant chess game where Ron actually shines and sacrifices himself, that hit me hard as a dude. Because finally it's not just the chosen one. It's the loyal friend showing a different kind of courage. And the final scene with Quirrell and the mirror is short, but heavy. Harry's scar burns, he doesn't understand anything, and what saves him is his mom's love, that old protection. It's simple. Not a powerful spell. It's love. And it works.

A lot of people complain the protections for the stone are dumb, that any first-year could solve them. And yeah, if you think like an adult, a three-headed dog that falls asleep to music? A trapdoor? Come on. But remember Dumbledore wanted Voldemort to try. It was a trap. And it was 1997, Rowling wanted adventure, not a security manual.

Scorecard

Plot: 8/10 - magical and nostalgic, but protections are weak

Characters: 9/10 - Hermione steals the whole show

Writing: 8/10 - simple, straight, no fancy BS

Pacing: 8/10 - start and end fly, middle slows down

Verdict

So is Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone worth it today, as a grown American man? Hell yeah. Worth it if you never read it because you thought it was just kids stuff. Worth it if you read it at 12 and never came back. It's not the most complex book in the world, not the best written, but it's got something a lot of tough-guy books don't have: it makes you feel at home. When you close it, you wanna stay five more minutes in Hogwarts. In today's world, loud and full of pressure, that's gold. It's a breather.

So tell me, are you Team A - Team Hermione, she carries the trio and should've been the chosen one - or Team B - Team Harry, the dude with his heart in the right place even when he's impulsive?

give it a Heart, leave a Comment, and Subscribe

RecommendationReviewReading Challenge

About the Creator

V.S Ferreira

Storyteller & Reader. I read trending books so you don't have to. No spoilers. No hype. Just honest reviews.

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by V.S Ferreira