01 logo

Xbox Fans Have Spoken and They Want the Old Xbox Back

Microsoft asked its users what they wanted. Turns out, they want everything Xbox has been quietly walking away from for years.

By Mark Lim Published 6 months ago • 3 min read
Xbox Fans Have Spoken and They Want the Old Xbox Back
Photo by Carl Raw on Unsplash

Xbox has been going through a bit of an identity crisis lately. Game Pass price changes, a rebrand that involved making the logo all-caps, first-party games showing up on PlayStation it's been a lot of shifts in a short amount of time, and not everyone is happy about the direction things are heading.

So Microsoft did something interesting. It launched the Xbox Player Voice essentially a Reddit-style feedback forum where users can post ideas and suggestions, and other players can upvote the ones they care about most. The top ideas get visibility with the teams that actually build Xbox features, though Microsoft was careful to stress that not every suggestion will become reality.

"Building across a large, global platform means weighing a lot of inputs," the company said. Fair enough. But the feedback that has risen to the top is pretty telling.

What Fans Actually Want

The single most upvoted topic on the entire platform, sitting at over 8,000 votes, is one word: EXCLUSIVES. All caps, no elaboration needed.

It's a loaded ask. Xbox has been moving away from traditional exclusives for a while now, with first-party games like Forza and Microsoft titles landing on PS5 and reportedly making a staggering amount of money doing so. Microsoft currently does timed exclusives, giving Xbox and PC players first access before games arrive on PlayStation. Pulling that back entirely would be a significant strategic reversal.

The new head of Xbox, Asha Sharma, has at least acknowledged the conversation, saying the company is trying to make "the right decision, not the fastest decision" on exclusives. Which is either reassuring or a very polished way of saying nothing, depending on your level of cynicism.

Meanwhile, Sony is reportedly moving back toward keeping its single-player story games exclusive to PS5 which only adds fuel to the fire for Xbox fans who feel their platform has lost its identity.

The Rest of the Wishlist

Beyond exclusives, the feedback forum reads like a love letter to the Xbox of 2008. Users want the backward compatibility program brought back over 6,000 upvotes for that one which allowed Xbox owners to play a huge library of older titles from previous generations. Free online multiplayer has racked up nearly 6,000 votes too, a throwback to the days before Xbox Live Gold became a requirement just to play games online with friends.

Improvements to the Xbox achievements system have gathered over 3,400 votes, suggesting that the gamerscore faithful are still very much out there and want the feature taken more seriously. A Game Pass family plan has also come up a reasonable ask given that every other subscription service on earth seems to offer one.

And then there's the charm stuff. Xbox avatars those little customisable digital characters that defined the Xbox 360 era have made a surprisingly strong showing in the feedback. User Christian Farrell summed it up well, noting that the avatars gave the Xbox 360 generation a genuine sense of identity that the platform has never quite recaptured since.

Physical game support for the upcoming next-gen console, Project Helix, has also come up a reflection of the ongoing tension between the industry's push toward digital-only and a fanbase that still values owning a disc.

So Will Any of This Actually Happen?

Hard to say. Microsoft has made some smaller moves recently a new green bootup animation, a refreshed logo, overhauled Gamerscore badges but those are cosmetic changes. The big asks from fans go much deeper than aesthetics.

What's clear is that Xbox has a community that remembers exactly what made the platform special, misses it, and is not shy about saying so. Whether Microsoft is actually listening really listening is the question that a feedback forum alone can't answer.

The votes are in. The ball is in Microsoft's court.

tech news

About the Creator

Mark Lim

Hi I am mark an automotive student and a car, tech and food enthusiast ! Im gonna try and post daily & hope you enjoy what I write and do share my page with people you know. I would gladly appreciate it! Cheers

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Mark Lim