01 logo

The Apple vs Epic Saga Has a New Twist and Apple Is Running Out of Arguments

Five years. This lawsuit has been running for five years, and Apple is still finding new ways to keep it going.

By Mark Lim Published 6 months ago • 3 min read
The Apple vs Epic Saga Has a New Twist and Apple Is Running Out of Arguments
Photo by Laurenz Heymann on Unsplash

Where Things Stand

If you've lost track of the Apple versus Epic Games saga, and honestly, who could blame you? Here's the short version. Epic, the company behind Fortnite, sued Apple in 2020 over the App Store's commission structure, arguing that forcing developers to use Apple's payment system and pay up to 30% on every transaction was anticompetitive. The courts mostly sided with Apple on the big antitrust questions, but did order the company to allow developers to include links in their apps pointing users toward payment options outside of Apple's ecosystem.

Apple complied with the letter of that order technically, but then charged a 27% fee on purchases made through those external links anyway. The court was not impressed. A contempt order followed, on the basis that charging fees on outside purchases defeated the entire purpose of allowing them in the first place.

Which, to be fair, it obviously did.

Apple's Latest Move

Rather than accept the contempt ruling and the implications it carries, Apple has now filed a petition asking the US Supreme Court to review the lower court's decision. And its argument this time is an interesting one.

Apple is essentially saying that Epic's dispute with Apple is Epic's dispute, not everyone's. The company argues that because Epic never filed a class action lawsuit and never sought to represent other developers, the resulting injunction shouldn't apply to all App Store developers, including giants like Microsoft and Spotify, who had nothing to do with this particular case.

"Epic never brought a class action and never attempted to show that enjoining Apple's conduct against all other developers like Microsoft or Spotify, who have nothing to do with Epic, was somehow necessary to provide relief to Epic," Apple's petition reads.

On the contempt order specifically, Apple is pushing back on whether a court can hold a company in contempt for violating the spirit of an injunction when the injunction itself never explicitly mentioned commissions on external purchases. The original court order said Apple had to allow links to outside payment options, but it didn't specifically say Apple couldn't charge fees on those purchases. Apple's argument is essentially: you didn't say we couldn't, so technically we didn't break any rules.

It's a narrow legal argument, and whether the Supreme Court will be interested in hearing it remains to be seen. Earlier this month, the court already rejected Apple's request to pause proceedings while it considered the case, which isn't exactly an encouraging sign for Apple's position.

What Epic Has to Say

Epic, predictably, is not taking this lying down. The company called Apple's Supreme Court petition "one last Hail Mary to delay a conclusion to this case and avoid opening up the gates to payment competition for the benefit of consumers."

Which is a pretty accurate description of what's happening, honestly.

Epic also made a move this week that signals its own confidence about where this is all heading. Fortnite returned to the App Store globally, with the exception of Australia. The company says it believes the courts will not allow Apple's current fee structure to stand, and it's acting accordingly.

The Bigger Picture

What makes this case so consequential is that it's not really just about Epic and Apple anymore. A ruling that forces Apple to genuinely open up its payment system without slapping equivalent fees on external transactions to render the whole thing pointless would reshape how the entire App Store operates for every developer on the platform.

Smaller developers who can't afford to fight Apple in court have been quietly watching this case for years, knowing that whatever outcome Epic wins or loses, they'll all be living with the consequences.

Apple, for its part, has essentially unlimited resources to keep fighting. The company has been at this for five years already and shows no sign of wanting to reach a conclusion. Every delay, every new petition, every procedural move buys more time before it has to fundamentally change how it makes money from the App Store.

Epic called it a Hail Mary. Maybe. But Apple has thrown plenty of those before and bought itself years in the process. Don't expect this one to end quickly either.

tech news

About the Creator

Mark Lim

Hi I am mark an automotive student and a car, tech and food enthusiast ! Im gonna try and post daily & hope you enjoy what I write and do share my page with people you know. I would gladly appreciate it! Cheers

Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.

Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.

Subscribe For Free

Reader insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment
    Written by Mark Lim