SpaceX Wanted to Rewrite the Rules of Going Public. The S&P 500 Said No.
Elon Musk has spent years doing things his own way
Elon Musk has spent years doing things his own way, and SpaceX's IPO was shaping up to be no different. The company is raising $75 billion at a target valuation of $1.75 trillion, which would place it among the ten most valuable publicly listed firms in the United States before a single trading day has passed. Musk had pushed for retail investors to receive a larger share of the allocation than is typical, structured the company's governance to preserve strong founder control, and most ambitiously lobbied for early inclusion in the S&P 500, the benchmark index that every major passive fund in America tracks.
On Thursday, S&P Global said no.
What the Rules Actually Require
The S&P 500 is not simply a list of the largest American companies. It has admission criteria, and one of the most significant is profitability. To join the index, a company must show a profit under Generally Accepted Accounting Principles in its most recent quarter, and for the sum of its four most recent quarters combined.
SpaceX does not currently meet that bar. Despite revenue growing 33% to $18.67 billion in 2025, the company posted a net loss of $4.94 billion for the year. By the S&P's existing rules, that disqualifies it regardless of its size, its ambitions, or the scale of its IPO.
S&P had spent recent weeks consulting investors about whether to change those rules for megacap companies: potentially shortening the time a company must be publicly listed before joining, waiving minimum float requirements, and removing the profitability requirement entirely. The consultation, widely understood to have been prompted in part by SpaceX's impending listing, concluded with S&P deciding to hold the line. Exceptions to the financial viability, seasoning, and investable weight factor requirements, the index provider said, should not be granted solely based on market capitalisation.
Why It Matters
The S&P 500 is Wall Street's most widely followed benchmark, and passive index funds tracking it hold trillions of dollars in assets. When a company joins the index, every fund that tracks it is obligated to buy its shares, which can drive significant demand and price movement. Had S&P changed its rules to admit SpaceX, that forced buying would have been enormous, given the company's valuation.
The decision to hold firm drew measured approval from market strategists. Maintaining a rules-based approach to index inclusion and insisting on profitability before entry was described as protecting the credibility of the benchmark itself. Making exceptions for companies large enough to demand them, the argument goes, sets a precedent that undermines the integrity of the index for everyone else.
The Doors That Did Open
SpaceX is not entirely locked out of index membership. Nasdaq has already amended its rules to make it easier for newly listed megacaps, including SpaceX, Anthropic, and other large private companies approaching public markets, to join the Nasdaq 100. Index funds tracking that benchmark will be required to buy SpaceX shares when it joins. S&P Global also said it would modify entry rules for its broader S&P Total Market Index and the Dow Jones U.S. Total Stock Market Index, giving SpaceX a pathway into those less prominent benchmarks. And FTSE Russell has separately announced fast-entry rules that make SpaceX eligible for its Russell U.S. Equity Indexes and FTSE Global Equity Index Series.
The S&P 500, however, remains out of reach for now, and with it, the automatic buying pressure from the world's largest passive funds.
SpaceX's IPO is arriving at a moment when US exchange operators are actively competing to attract large private companies to public markets, amid concern about the long-term decline in the number of listed American firms. AI giants Anthropic and OpenAI are among the other highly valued private companies edging toward public offerings, and the rules being written now about index inclusion, float requirements, and profitability thresholds will shape how those listings unfold.
For Musk, the S&P rejection is a setback rather than a crisis. SpaceX will still go public, still attract enormous investor interest, and still eventually become one of the most valuable companies in the world by market capitalisation. It will just have to earn its way into the most important index in American finance, the same way everyone else does, by turning a profit first.
About the Creator
Mark Lim
Hi I am mark an automotive student and a car, tech and food enthusiast ! Im gonna try and post daily & hope you enjoy what I write and do share my page with people you know. I would gladly appreciate it! Cheers
Enjoyed the story? Support the Creator.
Subscribe for free to receive all their stories in your feed.
Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.